Nick Butler: Thomas Bach finally dispels the myth that sport and politics do not mix

Nick Butler
Nick ButlerInternational Olympic Committee (IOC) President Thomas Bach has a knack of producing his best speeches when you are least expecting it.

In February at the Zimny Theatre in Sochi, the German delivered an address to open the IOC Session immediately after a speech by Russian President Vladimir Putin. Not having had the chance to hear a leading international statesman speak often, I was just finishing off an article leading with Putin's comments, when Bach launched into a venomous criticism of world leaders for "trying to score points" by missing the Winter Olympics. It forced a hasty rewrite.

Last Saturday (September 20) at the Olympic Council of Asia General Assembly in Incheon, something rather similar happened, Sitting in the back row in an early-morning, post Asian Games Opening Ceremony slumber, I pricked up my ears to hear Bach start redefining the sporting landscape.

"In the past, people have said sport is nothing to do with politics, or with money and business," declared the lawyer and former fencer. "This attitude is wrong and we cannot afford it anymore.

"We have to partner up with the politicians who are running this world, and with international Governments. To ensure the functioning of worldwide sport, we must be politically neutral but realise that our decisions have political implications."

Thomas Bach, speaking alongside OCA President Sheikh Ahmad Al Fahad Al Sabah, at the General Assembly in Incheon ©Getty ImagesThomas Bach, speaking alongside OCA President Sheikh Ahmad Al Fahad Al Sabah, at the General Assembly in Incheon ©Getty Images




It was not what he was saying that was so significant more the sheer fact he was saying this publicly. For it is the worst kept secret in sport that the Olympics and the IOC, as with the rest of the sports world, has been affected - controlled even - by political machinations ever since the Games began.

You would need a whole book to document the extent of this, but, for a brief introduction, Governments can promote sport to bring people together within their country, to provide an avenue for a restless youth or to raise the morale of a nation ravaged by other problems. The London 1948 Olympic Games, happening so soon after the Second World War, and Salt Lake City 2002, after 9/11, are two great examples. Construction required for hosting sporting events can also help regenerate communities or, alternatively, make problems worse, with Barcelona 1992 a case of the former and Montreal 1976 one for the latter.

In an international sense, a state can use sport to project a state to the world, from Adolf Hitler with his Nazi propaganda at Berlin 1936, to South Korea illustrating its shift from dictatorship to flourishing Asian "Tiger" at Seoul 1988, to the recent events in China and Russia designed to showcase the emergence, or re-emergence, of a global superpower.

All manner of people, ranging from athletes to Governments to external interest groups, can also use the Olympics as a platform to make a political point. Examples include the "Black Power" salutes by Tommie Smith and John Carlos at Mexico City 1968, the mass boycotts at Montreal 1976, Moscow 1980 and Los Angeles 1984, and the horrific terrorist attacks that scarred Munich 1972 and Atlanta 1996.

One of the most famous examples of the Olympics being used for a political protest: the Black Power Salute by Americans Tommie Smith and John Carlos at Mexico City 1968  ©AFP/Getty ImagesOne of the most famous examples of the Olympics being used for a political protest: the Black Power Salute by Americans Tommie Smith and John Carlos at Mexico City 1968
©AFP/Getty Images



The IOC and other governing bodies have always been affected by this. One recent example that comes to mind involves Kosovo, where the IOC are reluctant to grant Olympic recognition despite the majority of the international community recognising the Balkan Republic. Although there are other issues, the cusp of the matter is that , with Kosovan independence is such a divisive issue in international politics, and various influential countries remaining opposed, it is too much of a political risk. Others cases of this nature have occurred throughout the entire realm of Olympic history...

But in all this time the IOC and other sports bodies have resisted admitting such links exist. "Sport and politics should be kept apart", declared IOC President Avery Brundage in the 1930s. Eighty years later, Sochi 2014 chief Dmitry Chernyshenko effectively reiterated this. "Any political talks or discussions are not appropriate for the Olympic Games," he said. "The Olympics is not about politics."

Although sport has always maintained it can help make the world a better place, the fact that they have for so long avoided openly admitting its links to the real world, and occurrences therein, has been a central ambiguity. Yes, the Olympics has striven for "a peaceful society concerned with the preservation of human dignity", but can you really do this only by setting a sporting example, or do you have to direct integrate with the rest of the world?

That, I feel, is what Bach was getting at in his speech. In the last 12 months there has been a more outward, a more obvious, effort to court international leaders as well as to made an actual difference. In a release sent out to mark his one-year anniversary as President earlier this month, the IOC proudly wrote that he had already met 81 heads of State and Government, spanning countries across the world, of different political persuasion and with different levels of development.

Thomas Bach is developing increasingly close relations with Ban Ki Moon and the United Nations ©Getty ImagesThomas Bach is developing increasingly close relations with Ban Ki Moon and the United Nations ©Getty Images



In April, a "historic agreement was signed with the United Nations to "work together to build a better world through sport", with Bach delivering a speech at the UN General Assembly in New York before UN secretary-general Ban Ki-Moon returned the compliment in Sochi. An IOC President's Dinner - with 12 heads of state, four heads of Government and other major figures from business, media, science and culture - was held in Sochi, while a new "Sport for Hope" Centre has been opened in Haiti this year to accompany the one in Zambia opened under the leadership of former IOC President, Jacques Rogge. 

Finally, and perhaps most significantly, an emergency fund was set to Ukraine to help athletes at a time of political strife, with similar activism now being attempted in South Sudan and Central African Republic.

But as well, as this action, the sheer fact that Bach has admitted the hitherto unmentionable political influence, as well as the importance of "money and business", has shown that the IOC is a more open and honest organisation that no longer hides its real intentions.

An interesting contrast can be made her with football's world governing body, FIFA, that still insists it has an apolitical nature, even in the aftermath of the 2018 and 2022 FIFA World Cup events being awarded to Russia and Qatar in circumstances that could hardly have been more political.

FIFA still denies being politically influenced ©Getty ImagesFIFA still denies being politically influenced ©Getty Images



One final point that needs to be noted is that, when I asked the IOC for a copy of the speech, they did not have one, because, well, there wasn't one. "There were only bullet points, and the President largely improvised," I was told. Is it possible then, that Bach made a speech that can be seen as historically significant without really meaning to?

Yet whether he meant it or not, there is no doubt this is a message Bach is keen to get across. There are some purists who believe this is wrong, and that the IOC should still stay, or pretend to stay, apolitical, focusing only on sport. But in the ruthless world of realpolitik, this is nonsense.

As Bach says, the IOC must be alive to the times and must evolve as the world does. And by finally admitting a truth they have denied for generations, Bach is helping to rid the Olympic Movement of ambiguity and consequently position the Games all the more centrally in the 21st century world order.

Nick Butler is a reporter for insidethegames. To follow him on Twitter click here.

Paul Osborne: Polish fans give life lesson in support during incredible Volleyball World Championships

Paul OsbornePut 12,000 fans in an arena and they'll undoubtedly make some noise. Stick 12,000 Polish volleyball fans in a similar space and they'll create a symphony of shouts, screams, singing and song that'll have you searching the nearby seat for you recently misplaced ear drums.

Such was the atmosphere inside the Spodek Hall in Katowice, home to the finals of the FIVB Volleyball World Championships.

Now, I've been to many a football match in my time, albeit a fair few at the quarter-full Stadium:MK where the not-so mighty Milton Keynes Dons play their matches. I've even had the honour of gracing a fair few major sporting events, be it the London 2012 Olympic Games, the 2014 Commonwealth Games in Glasgow or the Nanjing 2014 Summer Youth Olympic Games.

None of these, however, have even come close to the noise and plain old raw passion seen, and heard, by the Polish fans here at the Volleyball World Championships.

Arriving on Friday, rest day at the Championships, I was blissfully unaware of the historic importance of volleyball across Poland, or Volleyland as I've since been taught.

The nation, and most importantly the city of Katowice, known for its love of the sport, is completely and utterly volleyball mad.

As Brits like myself could not live without their football (rugby or cricket for others, admittedly), the Poles feel similarly about their volleyball.

The Polish fans showed the world a lesson in support as they cheered their team all the way to victory at the FIVB Volleyball World Championships ©Getty ImagesThe Polish fans showed the world a lesson in support as they cheered their team all the way to victory at the FIVB Volleyball World Championships ©Getty Images



Despite a lull in major trophies over the past two-and-a-half decades, the sport is still the life and blood of the nation.

In fact the last time the national team had placed their hands on the flagship international title - the World Championships - was precisely 40 years ago to the tournament here in 2014.

What better way to celebrate this ruby anniversary than with a sea of red and white glistening across some of the biggest sporting venues throughout the nation? How about with victory over three-time defending champions Brazil? That'd work, I guess.

Not only did the Poles accomplish the feat earlier in the week, during their opening Round III fixture, they also happened to do it on the biggest international stage the sport has to offer.

The final here this evening was, quite possibly, the most incredible and hair-raising experience of my sporting days. Usually when watching a football match (or something similar) you'd expect decent fan participation for maybe 50/60 minutes of the 90 minute match.

Here, inside the Spodek Hall, the Polish fans were on their feet; singing, dancing, stomping and roaring for well over two-and-a-half hours.

Barely a minute could pass without a new chant, clap or rhythm being beat out by the truly phenomenal crowd.

Even falling a set down to the strong favourites didn't put a dampener on the fans as they ebbed their team through every point and urged them all the way to the world crown.

Victory for Poland earned them their first World title in exactly 40 years as they were urged all the way to the crown by a sea of red and white ©Getty ImagesVictory for Poland earned them their first World title in exactly 40 years as they were urged all the way to the crown by a sea of red and white ©Getty Images


That's obviously not taking anything away from the players who, for their part, played one of the most spectacular matches of the tournament as they crushed the ferocious Brazilian offence with an equally impressive defence.

But to see the obvious passion, bordering on derision, by the majority of fans here was simply spectacular.

I've never been to a volleyball match before to give my own personal comparison, however, I was told repeatedly that this sort of atmosphere is not normal.

Of course, volleyball is a massive global sport with nations such as Brazil, Italy and Russia also hugely passionate about the sport.

Nothing could prepare for the atmosphere here in Poland, though, as supporters went above and beyond the realm of normalcy to produce one of the most incredible sporting amphitheatres, I, and many others, have ever experienced.

Poland, Brazil and Germany pose on the podium after receiving their medals at the Volleyball World Championship at the Spodek arena in Katowice ©Getty ImagesPoland, Brazil and Germany pose on the podium after receiving their medals at the Volleyball World Championship at the Spodek arena in Katowice ©Getty Images

Even FIVB President Dr Ary Graça was in disbelief at the quality of the crowds when I spoke to him earlier today, telling me that their show was "a lesson to the rest of the world".

"It's a huge success these Championships all over the world," he told me. "We invest a lot of money, but the big star didn't need any money, and that's the public. They're giving their own show.

"I never saw such a thing before. I'm so proud of the public here in Poland. It's a lesson to the rest of the world. We're making videos to show other countries. Here it is spontaneous, and all the time! They don't stop shouting. I have to say to you that I am too much enthusiastic with what's happening here."

As has been said many times, and seen in practice, many times before, a crowd can make or break a match, event or even Championships. Here in Poland it has most certainly been the former and I agree with the President, the show put on by the Poles here in Katowice, and undoubtedly across the other four host cities, is quite simply a lesson for other nations, other sports and other fans right across the world.

Paul Osborne is a reporter for insidethegames. To follow him on Twitter click here.

Daniel Etchells: Fretting over the thought of fencing - my first out-of-office assignment for insidethegames

Daniel Etchells
Daniel Etchells ©insidethegamesMy first out-of-office assignment for insidethegames was always going to be filled with trepidation.

Not even my previous experience of covering Championship football matches for national newspapers on a freelance basis could prepare me for the task of single-handedly representing such a well respected company within the industry as a full-time employee.

Having been told on Monday (September 15), the day from which my contract commenced, that I will be travelling to Liechtenstein in October ahead of January's European Youth Olympic Festival, I knew the dress rehearsal - a trip to the Globe Theatre in London, synonymous with William Shakespeare - to cover an international fencing exhibition match between Great Britain and Germany, had to go to plan, or at the very least somewhere close to plan.

Donning a dark grey suit and my newly acquired insidethegames tie - bright green in colour with pink dots - wasn't entirely comfortable on a scorching hot Thursday afternoon but I had no other choice. Even my landlord expressed his sorrow for me as I set off for Bletchley train station with my hefty bag of journalistic tools hanging over my soon-to-be-sweaty shoulder

My only previous encounters with the sport of fencing had come sitting in front of a television but I was keen to remain open minded and embrace the evening to its fullest. In all honesty, I was primarily concerned about securing the necessary interviews and establishing a secure Wi-Fi connection inside the venue in order to be able to file my copy. The bane of most journalists' lives.

As well as writing this blog and reporting on the event, I was tasked with uploading photos to insidethegames' Facebook page, for which I had been assigned as an administrator. Taking pictures of the action and the venue seemed reasonably straightforward but naming people in captions far less so. The embarrassment of asking an "important looking person" for his or her name wasn't a particularly endearing prospect.

The Globe Theatre in London was a fitting venue for the exhibition ©Getty ImagesThe Globe Theatre in London was a fitting venue for the exhibition ©Getty Images





Not long after arriving,  I was introduced to British Fencing Association (BFA) chief executive Georgina Usher, who swiftly agreed to an interview. Sat on a bench overlooking the South Bank of the River Thames, she waxed lyrical about the sport she clearly loved and paid tribute to the BFA's sponsor Beazley, a specialist insurance company, who had put on the event along with many others around London in recent months. It seemed as though my illuminous tie was doing the trick.

"Any event which showcases fencing is fantastic," said Usher.

"For me fencing is such an amazing sport and it appeals to people of all ages. Events of this sort, at such a historic venue with the influence of Shakespeare and medieval sword play, are excellent."

As we strolled back inside, Usher suggested that I have a chat with the BFA's newly-appointed development director, Gabby Williams, to get an alternative perspective on the sport. Soon enough I was thrust into an interview with Williams, whose passion for fencing was evident from the moment I'd asked my first question. Although she made it clear that she had no previous background in the sport, the potential for growth is the biggest attraction in her eyes. 

"I'm not a fencer, so the experience and skills that I really want to bring into the role are very much around how to develop sport generally and how best to engage people in sport," said Williams.

"For me that's just making sure that we work with the right kind of partners in local communities where fencing hasn't traditionally been embraced previously.

"So as much as it's important to work with existing fencing clubs, I think likewise it's really important to work with more diverse agencies that can deliver the sport with us."

Two interviews in the bag before the event had barely even begun. Things were going well and they got even better when I was greeted with a full set of bars after logging into the venue's Wi-Fi. I managed to find a suitable vantage point overlooking the action and there were even plug sockets within reach to ensure a battery-less laptop wasn't going to ruin my night.

Germany beat Great Britain 45-34 at the International Fencing Challenge ©Beazley Germany beat Great Britain 45-34 at the International Fencing Challenge ©Beazley


I may not have got round to trying my hand at fencing as others did during the interval but I still had the feeling that I'd made a firm connection with the sport. From the people that I'd interviewed, I sensed a genuine appreciation simply for the fact that the event was being given media coverage. The realisation that they need us just as much as we need them really struck home and the BFA's retweet of my published article the following day was further evidence of that.  

I look forward to tracking the sport's progress in the coming months and years and hope to be given the opportunity to attend many more events of this kind. Having made plenty of contacts, I won't be fretting over the thought of fencing in the future. 

Daniel Etchells is a reporter for insidethegames. To follow him on Twitter click here.

Mike Rowbottom: Will it be Yes? Will it be No? Will it be Yo? Whatever, bring on the music...

Mike Rowbottom
Mike Rowbottom ©insidethegamesWill it be a Yes? Will it be No? Or will the people of Scotland vote Yo?  And what effect might this have upon British sport? All will be revealed, all too soon. But that is not what I want to talk about today...

Apart from to recall that most Scottish of laments, which I recall echoing around the old Wembley Stadium back in the early Seventies, to the tune of the 1969 John Lennon song Give Peace A Chance: "All we are say-ing, is give us a goal..."

There was something so mournful about it. Scotland gave only one goal to their resigned fans in those years - after a goalless draw in 1970, they lost 3-1 at Wembley in 1971, 1-0 at Hampden the following season, and suffered two defeats to the Auld Enemy in 1973, going down 5-0 at home in a friendly before another 1-0 defeat at Wembley. Sorry, Scotland, but them's the facts.

Scotland's Peter Cormack gets a cross in despite the attentions of Bobby Moore during England's 3-1 win at Wembley in 1971. The Scots sang "All we are say-ing is give us a goal", to the tune of John Lennon's Give Peace A Chance. But Scotland only managed one of those in five successive games against the Auld Enemy in the early 1970s ©Allsport/Getty ImagesScotland's Peter Cormack gets a cross in despite the attentions of Bobby Moore during England's 3-1 win at Wembley in 1971. The Scots sang "All we are say-ing is give us a goal", to the tune of John Lennon's Give Peace A Chance. But Scotland only managed one of those in five successive games against the Auld Enemy in the early 1970s ©Allsport/Getty Images

Had I been a little quicker off the mark, I might have submitted my memory for consideration to BBC Sport as it put together its recent package of Favourite Football Anthems. The list had some obvious entries - "You'll Never Walk Alone", the Rodgers and Hammerstein song from The Carousel given a classic Mersey makeover in 1963 by Gerry and the Pacemakers is, understandably, top selection in tandem with Liverpool FC.

As the footage of Anfield fans singing their signature tune during this year's 25th anniversary memorial service to the Hillsborough victims bears witness, music has a way of gathering massive emotion to it and, sometimes, giving expression to things never conceived of by its creators.

There were some other rightful inclusions too - Everton's Z Cars theme and West Ham's I'm Forever Blowing Bubbles. You could argue there should have been a place for more well-known footy ditties, such as Back Home, the England 1970 World Cup song - increasingly relevant to England's players at the World Cup these days. Or another 1960s pop classic, Glad All Over, loyally reprised at Selhurst Park on a regular basis, despite the fact that it was recorded by a band of Tottenham lads, the Dave Clarke Five, and features a production method known as the "Tottenham Sound".

The Dave Clarke Five pictured in 1963. Tottenham lads - but their classic song Glad All Over has been a theme tune for Crystal Palace FC down the years ©Hulton Archive/Getty ImagesThe Dave Clarke Five pictured in 1963. Tottenham lads - but their classic song Glad All Over has been a theme tune for Crystal Palace FC down the years ©Hulton Archive/Getty Images

As Gary Ream, the US-based President of the International Skateboarding Federation, said to me, fervently, this week: "Music is power."

I was talking to this hyper-enthusiastic proponent of his sport - believe me, this guy is always on a roll - on the subject of sport and television, but what Ream - is the "D" in his name silent, I wonder? - soon made abundantly clear was the complexity behind those two capital letters. And beyond that, the profound importance of musical backing.

"Skateboarding is a lifestyle sport so it's all about media, social media, the internet and TV," he said. "It's very visual. It's very popular with viewers. On TV, it has featured in ESPN's action sports network X Games, which has been running for about 15 years, it's been on NBC as part of the Dew Tour for the past eight or nine years, and Fox Sports  has been featuring Street League for six or seven years.

Skateboarders under Brooklyn Bridge in New York in 2010. Gary Ream, President of the International Skateboarding Federation, says music plays a crucial part in the promotion of this lifestyle sport ©Getty ImagesSkateboarders under Brooklyn Bridge in New York in 2010. Gary Ream, President of the International Skateboarding Federation, says music plays a crucial part in the promotion of this lifestyle sport ©Getty Images

"Some of the guys in Street League like Chris Cole or Sean Malto are making over $1 million (£613,000/€777,000) a year. When they came over to do the Sports Lab at the Youth Olympic Games in Nanjing they were probably the highest paid people present.

"People want to watch it. It's simple. And you can record street skateboarding on your smart phone and load it up directly to YouTube or whatever. You create new moves, you show them off, you record them, you add music, you upload them.

"When we took skateboarding off the streets in the 1980s, no one really cared. But now it has gone to a new level, and what is driving it is the passion of the kids who are doing it, and also documenting it, photographing it, recording it and creating videos and uploads with musical backing. Kids nowadays have access to video editing equipment that only people like Sony Studios had 15 years ago."

The same democratised dynamic, with music as the driving rhythm, exists within the sport of surfing, a companion of skateboarding in the X Games roster of cool.

A surfer at Bronte Beach, Sydney in 2012. Music and images combine to form a heady promotion for this coolest of sports ©Getty ImagesA surfer at Bronte Beach, Sydney in 2012. Music and images combine to form a heady promotion for this coolest of sports ©Getty Images

Get the mix of music and image right, and it is a heady brew - more than the sum of its constituent parts.

Personally, I don't surf the internet for slick moves I might emulate on the mighty ocean, nor do I investigate the latest smooth manoeuvres I might attempt as I skateboard to work, because I don't. But then, why would I? This is all the stuff of youth. I saw a 40-year-old in Notting Hill recently riding a skateboard, and I thought he looked, shall we say, a bit daft.

However, when it comes to trawling great goals from the Sixties, Seventies and Eighties, or perhaps personal choices of great goals encompassing some from that era, then I am your man. I recommend one recent example I discovered on a reconnaissance of great moments in Wolverhampton Wanderers' history. Don't ask. Anyway, here's the link to "my top 10 Wolves goals" - I promise you, the combination of action and music (127mph by True Love Always) is that heady brew.

Finally, to all you kids out there, all over the world, with your skateboards and your smart phones and your media savvy, I have this one simple message: Just Say Yo.

Mike Rowbottom, one of Britain's most talented sportswriters, covered the London 2012 Olympics and Paralympics as chief feature writer for insidethegames, having covered the previous five summer Games, and four winter Games, for The Independent. He has worked for the Daily Mail, The Times, The Observer, The Sunday Correspondent and The Guardian. His latest book Foul Play - the Dark Arts of Cheating in Sport (Bloomsbury £8.99) is available at the insidethegames.biz shop. To follow him on Twitter click here.

David Owen: Twilight of the football agents?

David OwenGiven the number of times I read that football agent Jorge Mendes won the summer transfer window, it is ironic that his profession stands technically to be legislated out of existence before the end of the 2014-15 season.

If world governing body FIFA gets its way, a new regulatory system dealing not with licensed agents, but with "intermediaries" will take effect on April 1 2015. Some, including agents I have spoken to who predict that the new rules will produce chaos, believe presumably that this date is all too appropriate.

One of the key points of the new regime is that intermediaries would not require a licence. Indeed, to judge by an email I received from an individual who had planned to secure his agent's qualification, only to be told that all examinations had been cancelled, in at least one country it is already impossible to actually qualify as a licensed football agent.

Instead, a registration system would be set up by national associations, and intermediaries registered for each deal they are involved in. Intermediaries would also have to sign a declaration for submission to the appropriate national association. This asserts, for example, that the person in question has an "impeccable reputation" and confirms in particular that "no criminal sentence has ever been imposed upon me for a financial or violent crime".

To me, it is as if mini-cars are to be allowed to operate in a market previously reserved for black cabs. However, FIFA argues that one of the main shortfalls of the current regulatory framework is that only 25 to 30 per cent of the international transfers are concluded through licensed agents.

FIFA's new regulatory system could, some fear, spark chaos ©Getty ImagesFIFA's new regulatory system could, some fear, spark chaos ©Getty Images



FIFA also stresses that the aim of the reform was "never to deregulate the governance of the activities of players' agents, but to propose a new system that is more transparent and simple to administer and implement, resulting, in turn, in better enforcement at national level".

What will be changed, FIFA continues, is "the focus of the regulations, away from regulating the access to the activity, towards a better control of the activity itself".

FIFA is also seeking to exert its influence on the vexed issue of agents' fees, saying the new regulations "attempt to provide for an overall rationalisation of fees paid to intermediaries by setting a limit of three per cent of the player's basic gross income, or of the transfer compensation, as a recommendation".

Quite how much of a difference this would make depends on whose assessment of the present state of the market you place most credence in. In January 2013, FIFA was reported to have said that agents took commissions averaging 28 per cent of cross-border deals in 2012. Yet when I heard Omar Ongaro, a member of FIFA's legal affairs unit, talk about the issue some four years ago, he suggested that the then average was about 10 per cent.

The Premier League has published figures showing that its 20 clubs paid £96.67 million ($157.8 million/€121.7 million) to agents over the year to September 30 2013. Their transfer spending in this period was some £750 million ($1.2 billion/€944.2 million), but I would presume that the £96.67 million would cover fees earned for contract extensions too.

A report by the CIES football observatory in February 2012 on football agents in the biggest five European markets, meanwhile, estimated that commissions paid to agents accounted for "about 3.5 per cent of the total money spent in salaries and transfer fees".

Unfashionable as it is to show any sympathy for agents, or intermediaries, as I suppose we are going to have to get used to calling them, who are popularly portrayed as scavengers sucking blood out of the game, I find it just as hard, frankly, to sympathise with clubs, the alleged victims


Clubs, to a significant degree, have brought this situation on themselves. They want success yesterday. That means they generally won't give the traditional football scapegoat - the coach/manager - time. So he, in turn, can't afford to give young players time to grow into their role. Safer to buy in the piece of his jigsaw puzzle that he thinks he is missing ready-made - an approach that very often will mean dealing with an agent, I'm sorry, intermediary.

Manchester United's Class of '92 shows patience from clubs can pay ©Getty ImagesManchester United's Class of '92 shows patience from clubs can pay ©Getty Images



I don't think it is a coincidence that the most noteworthy efflorescence of young talent at an English club seen in recent times - Manchester United's Class of '92 - came at a club that first had the patience to back manager Sir Alex Ferguson through three-and-a-half trophy-less seasons.

And if the short-termism of clubs, themselves stuffed to the gunnels with TV money, has had the effect of enriching top agents and their clients, it is little more than half a century since the, er, boot was very much on the other foot. Read Gary Imlach's hauntingly brilliant My Father and Other Working-Class Football Heroes for a vivid evocation of life when the average footballer's wages were £8 ($13.06/€10.07) a week. It should be required reading at every club academy.

It has become customary, as the war of words against agents has been prosecuted, for the sums paid to them in fees to be referred to as money "leaving the game". Yet the cash spent by players on tattoos and Lamborghinis, and by top executives on school fees and holiday homes, leaves the game just as definitively. And thank heavens for the sake of the wider economy that it does.

If I thought that eliminating agents, and hence cutting the costs run up by clubs in assembling and remunerating their playing staff, would result in lower prices for the everyday punter and/or increased investment in youth development, it might be a cause worth backing. But that is not how the brutal logic of the free market works. While demand for tickets outstrips supply, prices will tend to rise not fall. The money that used to be swallowed by agents, meanwhile, would more than likely pump yet more inflation into the transfer market or, at clubs not craving trophies or haunted by relegation, augment the rate of return enjoyed by owners.

The new regime is not yet a fait accompli: an agents' body has lodged a complaint and a challenge on anti-competitive grounds with the European Commission. Chances are you will be hearing an increasing amount on the subject between now and April Fools' day. When you do, it is perhaps worth reflecting on who stands to gain, as well as who stands to lose out, if the new rules do duly come into effect.

David Owen worked for 20 years for the Financial Times in the United States, Canada, France and the UK. He ended his FT career as sports editor after the 2006 World Cup and is now freelancing, including covering the 2008 Beijing Olympics, the 2010 World Cup and London 2012. Owen's Twitter feed can be accessed here.

Alan Hubbard: Scotland's sporting conundrum if it votes for independence would be more akin to a Shakespearean tragedy

Alan HubbardTo be or not to be. That is the question.

Hamlet's angst seems trite compared to the same poser faced by Scotland this week. To be or not to be Independent.

Actually, the question is simply Yes or No.

But it seems the two most crucial words are neither yes nor no, but Don't Know.

The Don't Knows in the opinion polls before the referendum are said to number around 20 per cent - so ultimately the current minority will decide Scotland's future; its politics and geopolitics, its economics, its currency and crucially for much of such a passionate population, its sport.

Who knows what the Don't Knows ultimately will favour?

Ironically, there is so much we don't know about the whole conundrum, not least the effect it will have on the games Scotland plays, who plays them and with whom, for generations to come.

Issues are being aired and angrily debated, if a little belatedly as panic sets in at Westminster and among those who orchestrate and administrate British sport.

The British government obviously hasn't a clue what will happen in the event of Scotland declaring a blue and white UDI. Neither does the government of sport on either side of the border, however much they may try to convince us otherwise.

A "yes" vote will spark tremendous uncertainty on both sides of the border ©AFP/Getty ImagesA "yes" vote will spark tremendous uncertainty on both sides of the border
©AFP/Getty Images



Then only certainty is uncertainty. It's an absolute mess. A maze of muddled thinking and conjecture.

There isn't a multi-sports body that has a clear view on what may lie ahead.

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) doesn't know. Nor the British Olympic Association, UK Sport, Sport England, sportscotland, or the umbrella "sports parliament", the Sport and Recreation Alliance, who at least have canvassed member organisations.

But they have to admit the overall reaction is one of uncertainty and lack of clarity. Everyone seems to be scratching their heads, simply acknowledging that it is one heck of a situation, but what to do about it no-one knows.

Scotland's handful of sporting superstars - who would certainly be a loss to a united GB - don't seem to know either. Or even want to know.

Take Andy Murray. Is he is likely to miss out on defending his Olympic title in Rio if Scotland decides to go it alone?

Sources at the IOC hint it would be "virtually impossible" to endorse Scotland as a separate country in time for the 2016 Games. So Murray, like other Scottish sportsfolk, will be sidelined unless they continue to choose to compete for Team GB, which surely would then make them ineligible to represent their new native country in the following Olympics in 2020.

Or, as insidethegames has pointed out, take up an IOC offer of participation under the Olympic flag with the Olympic anthem greeting them rather than "Flower of Scotland" should they make it to the winners' podium.

Hardly what Alex Salmond would want to see or hear.

Would Andy Murray have to sit out a title defence at Rio 2016, or compete under the British or Olympic Flag rather than that of a newly independent Scotland? ©Getty ImagesWould Andy Murray have to sit out a title defence at Rio 2016, or compete under the British or Olympic Flag rather than that of a newly independent Scotland? ©Getty Images



The yes-no vote presents an agonising tug-of-war for Scottish sport, and particularly those like Murray, who has been competing for Great Britain for 16 years. Murray, who does not have a vote as he now is resident in England - his Wimbledon home is just a short volley away from the scene of his history-making triumph last year - has always refused to be drawn on his views of Scottish independence, but asked during the recent US Championships who he would represent should Scotland split he said: "I imagine I would be playing for Scotland," adding: "But I haven't thought much about it yet because it is not looking too likely." That was before the latest polls dramatically narrowed the gap so he obviously now has some serious thinking to do.

Another Scottish high priest of sport who finds himself in a similarly tricky situation is Sir Craig Reedie. A former chair of the British Olympic Association and a principal architect of a successful London 2012, the 73-year-old Glaswegian is an influential IOC vice-president. He is known to be opposed to Scottish independence, yet wearing his IOC hat would be expected to help expedite Scotland's wish to compete separately in Rio.  However, he says he doubts there would be sufficient time for this to be ratified. "It would be very, very difficult because the IOC has tended to use recognition by the United Nations and I have no idea how long that would take."

We know too that it would also call into question Reedie's own role. Could he still represent GB on the IOC if Scotland, where he was born and still lives, becomes an independent nation?

Salmond has often been accused of using Caledonian sporting achievements for political gain. Not only did he pointedly flourish the Saltire in the Royal Box as Murray dutifully draped himself in the Union Jack after winning Wimbledon, but during London 2012 he had issued a good luck message urging people to cheer on the "Scolympians" - a combination of the words 'Scottish" and 'Olympians.'

This led to David Wilkie, their Olympic gold medal-winning swimmer, accusing the Scottish National Party government of trying to "hijack" the Commonwealth Games for political ends - a claim dismissed as unsubstantiated by Salmond's spokespeople.

Glasgow's successful staging of the Commonwealth Games this summer, and the success of home athletes, could sway some votes towards a "yes" ©Getty ImagesGlasgow's successful staging of the Commonwealth Games this summer, and the success of home athletes, could sway some votes towards a "yes" ©Getty Images



I was asked by BBC Scotland last week (would they still be able to call themselves BBC I wonder) whether I still held the view I expressed here that Glasgow's superb staging of the Commonwealth Games, and the any successes achieved in them by Scottish athletes, might help sway a yes vote.

I still believe it could if the feelgood factor, particularly among impressionable younger voters, has remained lodged in the consciousness.

However, my Glaswegian son-in-law, now domiciled in Surrey and so like Murray does not have a vote, disagrees.

A Celtic fan, he believes it more likely that fellow Scots would only be influenced by sporting issues to put their X in the yes box had their football team actually beaten world champions Germany in the recent European Championships qualifier. Such joy really would have been unconfined.

The greatest temptation for sporting Scots to subscribe to the view that we are better together is based on funding and facilities.

Around 11 per cent of the athletes on UK Sport's world-class programme, which distributes £350 million ($565 million/€437 million) of exchequer and National Lottery funding every four years, are Scottish. But Scottish athletes made a contribution to one in five of the 65 medals won in London by Team GB.

British sport is 60 per cent funded by lottery (and pro rata ticket sales are said to be high in Scotland than in England) and 40 per cent by the UK Government.

The lottery funding settlement for Scotland, should it become independent, remains up in the air ©Getty ImagesThe lottery funding settlement for Scotland, should it become independent, remains up in the air ©Getty Images



Supporters of Scottish nationalism have insisted that its share of the actual lottery investment in sport - estimated at around £37 million ($59 million/€46 million) – should simply be transferred to sportscotland. But the Government is understood to be adamant that the entire basis of the lottery funding settlement would have to be revisited.

Then there is another unanswered question. For whom will Scots compete in the qualifying competitions in the 18 months before the Games? Would Britain continue to select Scots in its teams in the wake of a yes vote?

Would UK Sport, which funds elite athletes, continue to bankroll Scots? Would it allow them to continue to train at its elite performance centres, most notably English Institute of Sport in Sheffield?

UK Sport's chief executive, Liz Nicholl, can only say at the moment that a yes vote would weaken the medal chances of both Scottish athletes and their British counterparts.

The British Olympic Association (BOA), chaired by Lord Coe, said it had not formed a view on what it would do if Scotland voted for independence.

"At this point in time, Team GB is made up of athletes from all eligible home nations and territories," say the BOA. "Once the referendum result is known, we will look at the possible consequences for a British Olympic team and act accordingly."

In other words, like the rest of us, even Lord Coe and co are Don't Knows.

All we do know is that should Scotland decide to do its own thing, Olympic sport will be left with a whole raft of problematical questions plus the real danger that any chance of Murray and co travelling the rocky road to Rio behind the Saltire rather than the Union Jack will disappear into a Scotch mist.

So never mind the Prince of Denmark's dilemma. What will happen if Scotland says "aye" on Independence Day is more akin to another Shakespearean tragedy much closer to home: Macbeth. "Hubble, bubble toil and trouble" Yes indeed. A real Witches' Brew.

Alan Hubbard is an award-winning sports columnist for The Independent on Sunday and a former sports editor of The Observer. He has covered a total of 16 Summer and Winter Games, 10 Commonwealth Games, several football World Cups and world title fights from Atlanta to Zaire.

Nick Butler: Scottish Independence would raise many questions for Olympic Movement

Nick Butler
Nick ButlerI was impressed at how sport was so strongly at the centre of attention during the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow, with political matters relegated to the back seat.

But, fast forward a few weeks, and the country is awash with the fervour of the impending Scottish Independence referendum.

On Thursday (September 18), all residents of Scotland over the age of 16 - so including my staunchly English cousin who has just started as a BP graduate in Aberdeen, but not a born and bred Scotsman, who has just moved south of the border - will cast a historic vote that could pose huge ramifications for the rest of the United Kingdom, not to mention farther afield.

As someone interested in history and politics, I am finding it all absolutely fascinating. Aside from the issues themselves, you have the personalities involved, the strategy of the campaign trail and the never-ending deluge of statistics, predictions and polls, plus the vast number of issues caught in the cross-fire, be they in relation to politics, energy, defence and, of course, sport.

For one of the first occasions in my memory, the three major British political parties are united in their opposition to independence, and virtually all arms of the English press are also singing from the same unionist hymn sheet. This makes for some fascinating coverage, with a mock-up of Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond with the haircut of North Korean leader Kim Jong-un, to illustrate the possible alliance between the two regimes, my favourite.

The Scottish independence question is becoming ever more interesting with just three days to go until the referendum ©Getty ImagesThe Scottish independence question is becoming ever more interesting with just three days to go until the referendum ©Getty Images



But you also have to remember that everything you read is subject to vested interests either way, with the prospects of a Scottish Olympic team at Rio 2016 a good example of this.

Last week, international Olympic Committee (IOC) President Thomas Bach spoke about how they respect "democratic decisions" and, if a yes vote was to occur, they would "safeguard the interests of the athletes" and try their best to include Scottish participants in Rio.

As well as Reuters, to whom the comments were initially made, these words were reported by all of the Olympic press, including insidethegames, as well as by the Scottish Herald. But no other newspaper or website in England seems to have done so, focusing only on the words of Great Britain's IOC vice-president Sir Craig Reedie, who has said it will be "difficult" for a Scottish team to be set up in time for Rio.

Although Bach's words do not really signify much difference from those of Sir Craig, the reluctance to publish something which comes even close to being positive for the pro-independence side indicated just how partisan the media, like all other platforms, has become in this most divisive of contests.

Lengthy discussions involving the likes of Thomas Bach (left) and Sir Craig Reedie will have to take place should Scotland vote for independence ©Getty ImagesLengthy discussions involving the likes of Thomas Bach (left) and Sir Craig Reedie will have to take place should Scotland vote for independence ©Getty Images



To be able to compete in the Olympics, a country must fulfil two objectives. It must be an "independent state recognised by the international community", a stipulation that is currently defined by membership of the United Nations, and it must have at least five national sporting federations recognised by the respective international body. As, in the case of a yes-vote, there will be an 18 month preparation before independence is formally declared on March 24, 2016, there would be very little time to fulfil either part.

With the situation less politically divisive in a global sense than that facing Kosovo, another nation currently striving for IOC recognition, there is a possibility that recognition of a Scottish NOC could be fast-tracked in some way. Yet this move would be unlikely to be met with unanimous support by the IOC as a whole, particularly from members from countries, such as Spain, who will be reluctant to encourage separatist groups within their shores.

This means that Scottish athletes remaining part of Great Britain or competing as independent athletes under an Olympic Flag is more likely. This latter option is what Macedonian athletes did at Barcelona 1992 because the new countries NOC was not recognised in time. East Timor at Sydney 2000 and South Sudan at the Nanjing 2014 Summer Youth Olympic Games last month have also previously competed under the Olympic Flag. 

But, even if Scottish athletes are able to compete in Rio, there would be other challenges. Would they be eligible for National Lottery Funding, for instance? Would they be able to take advantage of training facilities south of the border? And what would happen if a Scottish athlete, particularly in a sport like rowing or cycling, is reluctant to forego successful partnerships with English team mates and wishes to stay under the umbrella of Great Britain?

As it stands, tennis player Andy Murray remains the only Olympic sportsperson who has declared that they will compete for an independent Scotland over Britain, even though he claims to be neutral on the question of independence. Unlike most others, he is not dependent on National Lottery Funding.

With Andy Murray, Sir Chris Hoy, Katherine Grainger, Heather Stanning, Tim Baillle among those adding to a rich litany of Scottish Olympic success as part of a British team in London, a subject which my colleague Philip Barker has already considered in detail, a British team would be far weaker without its Scottish core. In winter sports, where Scots make up the majority of the British team, including the entirety of the curling squads that won silver and bronze earlier this year in Sochi, there would be an even more divisive affect.

Every member of the medal winning male and female British curling squads at Sochi 2014 was Scottish ©Getty ImagesEvery member of the medal winning male and female British curling squads at Sochi 2014 was Scottish ©Getty Images



Then there is the question of the IOC members. Would Sir Craig represent Scotland or Britain? Also, with Adam Pengilly and Sir Philip Craven reaching the end of their terms at the IOC Athletes' Commission and International Paralympic Committee in four and three years time respectively, could Princess Anne, who is also the Patron of the Scottish Rugby Union, be left as the only British IOC member? Leading to greater opportunities, consequently, for the likes of Sebastian Coe and International Cycling Union President Brian Cookson?

Outside the Olympics, Scottish independence poses many other sporting questions. One involves Scotland's bid to host matches during the Euro 2020 football tournament. Another involves whether the British and Irish Lions Rugby team would have to change their name, and a third involves the British Open, one of four majors on the golfing calendar. It has been confirmed that The Open will definitely be played on Scottish soil at St Andrews in 2015 and Royal Troon in 2016 regardless of the referendum result, but questions remain for the long-term as to whether Scottish courses could still be used.

None of this will matter if Scotland does not vote yes, and according to most opinion polls, a no-vote remains the narrow, the very narrow, favourite. But with three days to go, we have now reached a late, but tremendously pivotal stage in the campaign as the countdown to finals day draws near.

I received my first opportunity to see Alex Salmond in the flesh when he spoke to the press shortly before the Opening Ceremony of Glasgow 2014. Although he insisted over and over again that he would maintain a "self-denying ordinance" for the duration of the Games but could not resist following that with a quick dig about British Chancellor George Osborne paying such a brief visit to Glasgow, I have to say I was impressed.

To borrow a football analogy, he is a Roy Keane-esque street fighter, a Mario Balotelli-like maverick, and an instinctive risk-taker in the Louis van Gaal mould all rolled into one. He stands in perfect contrast to the more stoic Better Together movement, although the drive for unity has been spearheaded, as of this week, by former British Prime Minister Gordon Brown. He resembles a sacked international football manager given a second lease of life back at the cosier familiarity of club level, I feel, and he appears to be relishing every second of it.

Figures including First Minister Alex Salmond and former British Prime Minister Gordon Brown have three more days to perfect their respective campaigns ©Getty ImagesFigures including First Minister Alex Salmond and former British Prime Minister Gordon Brown have three more days to perfect their respective campaigns ©Getty Images



Time will tell whether the finishing skills of either Salmond or Brown best resemble Diego Costa or Yaya Sanogo, but like the countdown to a World Cup Final, the next three days promises to be equally as exciting and nerve wracking in equal measure.

And while interest levels will be rising throughout Scotland from the southern borders to the Outer Hebrides, those elsewhere, from the corridors of Lausanne to the London headquarters of the British Olympic Association, will also be watching intently.

Nick Butler is a reporter for insidethegames. To follow him on Twitter click here.

David Owen: Having bought into Putin’s nation-building project, is sports overexposed to threat of a new Cold War?

Duncan Mackay
David Owen ©ITGRecent reports suggesting that European Union countries were mulling a possible future sports boycott against Vladimir Putin's Russia triggered two immediate thoughts.

1. How quickly the world can change. It was only at the start of this year, after all, that the furore over LGBT rights appeared ultimately to have reinforced what has tended to be the mainstream view on sporting boycotts for the past couple of decades: that they mainly hurt the countries embarking on them, in particular their athletes.

While a number of political leaders found reasons to stay away from the Sochi 2014 Winter Olympic Opening Ceremony, at no stage did there seem more than the slenderest chance that any of the major teams would pull out of what was a spectacular Russian prestige event.

2. How extensively world sporting leaders have bought into Putin's grandiose national pride through sport project.

The Big Two international events for Russia are of course the Winter Olympics and Paralympics, which took place in Sochi earlier this year, and the 2018 FIFA World Cup.

But the list of major international championships earmarked for the country is formidably extensive.

This year, as well as Sochi 2014, there were World Championships in judo and fencing.

Oh and a debut Russian Formula One grand prix is to be held next month, also in Sochi.

Next year will bring the World Aquatics Championships to Kazan and (again) the World Fencing Championships, this time to Moscow, while the SportAccord convention, one of the sporting world's most important annual get-togethers, is due to be held in Russia for the second time in three years.

In 2016, it is the turn of ice-hockey and that sport's World Championship.

There has also been a World Athletics Championships along the way, in the capital Moscow in 2013.

Russian leader Vladimir Putin, pictured here with International Olympic Committee President Thomas Bach, was closely associated with the success of Sochi 2014  ©AFP/Getty ImagesRussian leader Vladimir Putin, pictured here with International Olympic Committee President Thomas Bach, was closely associated with the success of Sochi 2014
©AFP/Getty Images


As I write this, a ceasefire in Eastern Ukraine appears to have taken some of the immediate sting out of the diplomatic situation.

Yet there remains a sense that things could start sliding downhill again with little warning.

And if that happens, leading to a further, prolonged deterioration in relations between Russia and the West, it would be hard not to conclude that the sports sector is exposed to a worrying degree.

Yes, if push came to shove, alternative hosts could no doubt step into the breach for most or all of these events.

But such late rearrangements would have cost implications, as would pressing ahead with the events in Russia under circumstances inducing many leading athletes, and perhaps other stakeholders, to stay away.

Aspirations of expanding the Russian market for western sporting goods, moreover, would probably have to be put on ice.

Already, the sportswear group Adidas has decided to "significantly reduce its store opening plan in the market for 2014 and 2015, and to further increase the number of store closures", although it remains "very encouraged by increasing brand momentum".

Sportswear giants Adidas have announced plans to scale back their presence in Russia since the start of the Ukraine crisis ©AFP/Getty ImagesSportswear giants Adidas have announced plans to scale back their presence in Russia since the start of the Ukraine crisis ©AFP/Getty Images

Prudence, surely, would now dictate that sports property owners think very carefully before bestowing more future sports events on Russia. Not that they are as spoilt for choice, many of them, as they have sometimes been in the past.

Citizens in several comparatively cuddly and affluent western democracies are manifesting considerable scepticism about the local benefits of hosting big sporting events - especially when irritants such as road works and higher taxes are sometimes all too apparent.

And the street demonstrations in Brazil ahead of this summer's ultimately very successful World Cup were so widely reported that they may give pause for thought to other ambitious countries contemplating hosting sports events as a means of fostering national development.

Such reactions have been among factors propelling events to places such as China, the Gulf states and Russia, where well-resourced, efficient organisation is assured and the general public is less inclined to make a fuss.

The United States, at least, seems increasingly determined to win the right to host the Summer Olympics for the first time since 1996.

The appetite for staging other events that often accompanies such ambitions may be fortuitously-timed from the sports sector's point of view.

Having lost out to Qatar in the controversial race for the 2022 World Cup, the US looks well-placed to host that mega-event for a second time in the not too distant future as well.

One possible Russian project whose prospects have probably been dented by current tensions between Russia and the West is a St Petersburg bid for the 2024 Olympics and Paralympics.

With bids needing to be launched next year, the diplomatic situation would have to thaw markedly for such a venture to stand any chance of success.

And yet you could say that a St Petersburg Olympics - not in 2024, but between, say, 2028 and 2036 - would be the logical culmination of Putin's nation-building international sports policy.

Any hopes St Petersburg had of bidding for the 2024 Olympics and Paralympics has probably been ended by recent political events but the Russian city remains a contender in the future ©AFP/Getty ImagesAny hopes St Petersburg had of bidding for the 2024 Olympics and Paralympics has probably been ended by recent political events but the Russian city remains a contender in the future ©AFP/Getty Images

Clamping my rose-tinted spectacles firmly to my head, therefore, it could be argued that sport provides a motive for Putin, who can act more nimbly than the West with its cumbersome international policy-making apparatus, not to allow relations with Washington and Brussels to deteriorate beyond repair.

It would be almost unthinkable, even allowing for the sprinkling of Putin allies who hold prominent positions in the world of international sport, for St Petersburg to win the Games in the event of a flat-out new cold war.

Yet Putin knows how easily he has charmed international sports decision-makers in the past - both in Guatemala, where his English speech in 2007 did much to win the day for Sochi, and three years later in Zurich, where his decision to stay aloof from the futile, last-gasp World Cup lobbying appeared in retrospect both well-judged and dignified.

It would not take much, I suspect, for this artful, intimidating and powerful man to have the grandees of international sport once again feeding out of his hand.

For the time being, though, I would think that the list of prestigious international sports events that are heading for Russia will stop getting longer.

David Owen worked for 20 years for the Financial Times in the United States, Canada, France and the UK. He ended his FT career as sports editor after the 2006 World Cup and is now freelancing, including covering the 2008 Beijing Olympics, the 2010 World Cup and London 2012. Owen's Twitter feed can be accessed here.

Mike Rowbottom: How sport gets in a fix - even if there isn't a fix

Mike Rowbottom
Mike Rowbottom ©insidethegamesAnyone who has ever attended a football match will recognise one of the deepest instincts of the spectator - the urge to shout out "handball!"

It's unnecessary. That's what the referee and assistants are there for. And if they don't perceive such an offence, then shouting out "handball" is irrelevant. But that urge to shout - it's as irresistible as a doctor's rubber hammer to a bent knee.

We engage at a number of levels with any sporting spectacle - we judge, we evaluate, and sometimes we react, even if we would be hard pushed to explain why.

Within the space of the last seven days, two sporting encounters have provoked instinctive reactions among some of those who have witnessed them, raising suspicions about their validity.

Important note here - just because suspicions are raised, it doesn't mean they have foundation; in just the same way, not every instinctive cry of "handball!" is correct.

The manner in which Britain's Mo Farah won Sunday's 34th running of the Great North Run generated a fair amount of questioning on Twitter. Kenyan Mike Kigen - a training partner of Farah's and a fellow member of the PACE management group - appeared to have a chance of breaking away from the world and Olympic 5000/10,000 metres champion but was eventually beaten by a sprint over the final 200m, albeit that he recovered ground to record the same winning time of one hour exactly.

Mo Farah finishes narrowly ahead of training partner Mike Kigen at Sunday's Great North Run - a result which caused some speculation ©Getty ImagesMo Farah finishes narrowly ahead of training partner Mike Kigen at Sunday's Great North Run - a result which caused some speculation ©Getty Images

Farah was obliged to address the question in his post-race interview. He said he and Kigen had planned to "work together" to see off all other opposition - which included Uganda's world and Olympic marathon champion Stephen Kiprotich - adding:

"Mike is a great athlete and in great shape. He pushed the pace on and kept pushing and pushing. There were a couple of times I was struggling but I managed to get back to him. I knew if it came down to the finish I could use my sprint finish, but today he actually did test me and I believe he could have run a lot faster if he had people to go with.

"If it wasn't for how high he thinks of me, he could have really had a go at one point."

But when asked whether Kigen had slowed at any point to let him catch up, Farah responded with a laugh: "No".

Asked if he could have broken away when he opened up a five-metre lead at 10 miles, Kigen responded: "No I couldn't. I'm happy with second place. I was trying to push but I know Farah in the last mile is so strong."

Three days before the Great North Run, the manner of Australia's 91-83 defeat by Angola in a FIBA Basketball World Cup group match triggered more serious suspicion, to the point where the International Basketball Federation announced they were opening disciplinary proceedings against the losers.

After resting several of their strongest players, including star centre Aron Baynes, the Australians - who subsequently lost their quarter-final against Turkey by a single point - let a 15-point lead slip against their African opponents.

Australia's defeat by Angola at the Basketball World Cup last week is now being investigated by the world governing body ©AFP/Getty ImagesAustralia's defeat by Angola at the Basketball World Cup last week is now being investigated by the world governing body ©AFP/Getty Images

A FIBA statement read: "The on-court behaviour displayed by Australia in that game generated huge disappointment by basketball fans and experts.

"It is widely suspected that Australia lost that game in order to avoid having to face the reigning world champions USA until the semi-finals."

Basketball Australia plans to make a vigorous defence of its team, saying in a statement:

"The Australian Boomers went into the game against Angola to win - plain and simple.

"Claims to the contrary are widely speculative, insulting to the Australian sporting culture and to our playing group who gave their very best throughout this tournament.

"They're downright wrong."

Farah has denied any fixing; and as matters stand, no charges are proven against Australia's basketball team.

But these two cases are merely the latest examples to have occurred in two sporting areas which have, historically, generated suspicions and ambiguities down the years.

Farah's phrase "how high he thinks of me" is interesting. The obvious interpretation, backed up by Kigen's comment, is that the Kenyan runner simply did not believe, given what he knew of Farah's talent, that he could realistically hope to break away and win. But there is an element in this phrase also which hints at something beyond respect. It almost suggests Kigen would think it wrong to challenge Farah.

Only Kigen will know the truth of the matter.

It is well acknowledged that middle distance and longer distance running has always involved elements of collusion in races - unofficial partnerships or agreements between competitors, often but not always of the same nationality, even in races were overt assistance is being offered in the form of pacemakers travelling at speeds agreed by the main players.

At the 1993 International Association of Athletics Federations World Cross Country Championships held in Amorebieta. Spain, running as a team was an intrinsic part of the event, given that the team championship ran in tandem with the individual race.

But such was the Kenyan domination of the race that they were able to openly manipulate the individual honours at the same time as securing their national victory. After William Sigei - who would break the world 10,000m record the following year - had taken the gold, it transpired he had been effectively waved through by his fellow Kenyans on the instruction of their coach, who explained to me and other questioning members of the press afterwards that Sigei had proved himself the best runner in training.

Sigei's victory in the men's senior event, which was led for all but the finishing straight by his teammates Dominic and Ismail Kirui, was worked out to the last detail. "In the last five hundred metres I slowed my speed so that Sigei could come through," Dominic Kirui said. "In our training before the race, when we were doing speed work, we saw that Sigei was just better. It was decided that Ismail and I would make good pacemakers for him."

The man who laid the plans, Kenya's national coach, Mike Kosgei, beamed with pride afterwards. "Sigei was our darling in the race," he said. "When he was running on his own in third place, I told him to stay there. We didn't want anybody to jostle or spike him."

Moving back to the case of the Australian basketball team - however the allegations play out, this is no more than the latest instance of suspicions being raised because of a competitive framework which is open to the possibility of manipulation.

At the 1982 World Cup finals, similar disquiet was raised by the final Group B match between West Germany and Austria. Because all the other qualification matches had already been played, the two neighbours were able to go into their meeting knowing exactly what they needed to do to ensure progression.

A 1–0 win for the Germans would suit both teams perfectly. Horst Hrubesch put West Germany ahead after ten minutes, after which the match effectively ended as a competition. Despite boos and whistles from the crowd the phoney contest continued until the final whistle.

Algeria, the team that missed out on qualification in the same group, protested to FIFA, but to no avail. However, at the Mexico World Cup four years later, FIFA ensured that the last round of matches in the group stage took place simultaneously.

West Germany's Horst Hrubesch celebrates scoring the goal which earned his side a 1-0 win over Austria in a Group B match at the 1982 World Cup which saw both teams progress to the next round, provoking a protest - and a subsequent rule change ©Getty ImagesWest Germany's Horst Hrubesch celebrates scoring the goal which earned his side a 1-0 win over Austria in a Group B match at the 1982 World Cup which saw both teams progress to the next round, provoking a protest - and a subsequent rule change ©Getty Images

At the 2009 Asia Pacific Bowls Championships in Kuala Lumpur the New Zealand four skipped by Gary Lawson - a player who had been gloriously described as "the Bad Boy of New Zealand bowls" - were accused of throwing their last group game in order to manipulate a better draw in the knockout stages. The consequent maths within their group meant that Canada missed out on progressing, and the Canadians, suspicious, asked Bowls New Zealand to investigate. All were reprimanded, and Lawson was banned for six months.

Three years after the Bad Boy had become the Banned Boy, there was a similar to-do over deliberate defeats - but this time the sport was not bowls, but badminton, and the controversy took place at the London 2012 Olympics, as bad luck would have it, on the day when the International Olympic Committee's President, Jacques Rogge - who had sounded a clear warning on the danger of match fixing in world sport a year before the Games had got underway - had been a spectator at the Wembley Arena on the day.

Four of the teams in the women's doubles were disqualified on the ruling relating to "not using one's best efforts to win". Matches between two South Korean pairings and their Chinese and Indonesian opposition turned into a shuttlecock version of a slow bicycle race as the teams appeared to be outdoing each other in their efforts not to win, methods of which included deliberately missing shots and serving woefully.

An official steps during a badminton match between Indonesia and South Korea at the London 2012 Olympics. Eight players in the women's doubles competition were disqualified for not using best efforts to win ©Getty ImagesAn official steps during a badminton match between Indonesia and South Korea at the London 2012 Olympics. Eight players in the women's doubles competition were disqualified for not using best efforts to win ©Getty Images

The expelled players included Chinese world champions Wang Xiaoli and Yu Yang, who were accused by other players of attempting to throw their "dead rubber" game in order to avoid playing China's number two ranked pair before the gold-medal match. The Chinese players' actions appeared to trigger a response from pairs from South Korea and Indonesia, who in turn tried to lose to counter the Chinese intentions.

Thomas Lund, chief executive of the BWF, made a careful statement to reporters in the aftermath of the controversy: "I would like to underline that it is the responsibility of the players, and team members, and the entourage around them to live up to the standards in our regulations - the players' code of conduct - to go after winning every match. That's the bottom line."

But the competition format was subsequently changed so that the same temptation will not be there at future Olympics. Sometimes that's all it takes to erase the grey areas in sport. Sometimes the answer is not so simple.

Mike Rowbottom, one of Britain's most talented sportswriters, covered the London 2012 Olympics and Paralympics as chief feature writer for insidethegames, having covered the previous five summer Games, and four winter Games, for The Independent. He has worked for the Daily Mail, The Times, The Observer, The Sunday Correspondent and The Guardian. His latest book Foul Play – the Dark Arts of Cheating in Sport (Bloomsbury £8.99) is available at the insidethegames.biz shop. To follow him on Twitter click here.

David Owen: Bach - an impressive first year; now the hard part begins

Duncan Mackay
DavidOwenOn July 8, Thomas Bach rounded off the second day of an International Olympic Committee (IOC) Executive Board meeting by watching in the foyer of Lausanne's Palace hotel as his native Germany trounced hosts Brazil 7-1 in a FIFA World Cup semi-final.

Since his election as IOC President in Buenos Aires a year ago, on 10 September 2013, Bach and his team have often looked as slick and well-organised as that world champion German side; but - one year into a potentially 12-year reign - it is much too soon to judge whether they will accomplish their aims so completely.

That is not to say, stretching the analogy to breaking-point, that the 60-year-old athlete-turned-administrator has not nodded in the odd early goal.

Chief among these, by my estimation, is the $7.65 billion (£4.51 billion/€5.49 billion) deal, unveiled last May, selling United States broadcasting rights to the Olympic Games between 2021 and 2032 across all media platforms to NBCUniversal (NBCU).

Yes, some might argue - given how profoundly the media world will change over the next two decades, and that the sums involved average out, by my calculation, to around a 16 percent increase per four-year Olympic cycle over the last deal - that Bach may turn out to have underplayed his hand and would have done better not to commit so far into the future.

A more pragmatic appraisal in my view is to acknowledge that a solid financial base has been put in place - equivalent to perhaps 20 per cent of the revenue that the Movement would realistically want to have at its disposal over the deal's 12-year span.

This may give the IOC the security to negotiate more aggressively with other media partners, should it deem individual markets strong enough.

It should be remembered too that broadcasting revenues, though resilient, will show far slower growth in the 2013-2016 quadrennium than the explosive near 50 percent advance the Movement benefited from in 2009-2012.

In such circumstances, the latest NBCU deal also sends out a strong message to other potential commercial partners about the long-term desirability of the Olympic property.

In a second important point, I think the NBCU deal indicates the limits of the collegial management style the IOC President has appeared to set so much store by during his first months in office.

When Bach, fresh from addressing the United Nations, first broached the idea of what I think may fairly be called the IOC's deal of the century (so far), last November at a New York dinner with NBCU executives, he was accompanied by just two senior IOC officials.

"We kept it among the three of us," he later confided.

Thomas Bach has reinjected momentum into the Olympic Movement since replacing Jacques Rogge as IOC President exactly a year ago ©Getty ImagesThomas Bach has reinjected momentum into the Olympic Movement since replacing Jacques Rogge as IOC President exactly a year ago ©Getty Images

Another big achievement of the first 12 months of the Bach era has been to reinject momentum into a Movement that had been rather drifting along in the final phase of Jacques Rogge's Presidency.

Rogge's great accomplishment was to restore the IOC's reputation for integrity.

This was no small thing: the financial bonanza which the unfailingly serious Belgian presided over, as the world's most powerful political leaders, and business and television executives, fought for a piece of the Olympic action, would probably have been a lot less lucrative without that first step.

When it came to the vision thing, though, the Rogge regime inspired far less confidence, with the jury, for me, still out on whether his baby, the Youth Olympic Games, is an effective - and cost-effective - way of enticing young people to engage with the Movement.

With the benefit of hindsight, his second term was perhaps a mistake - and the sheer number of balls Bach has thrown up into the air since his election is perhaps a reflection of that.

One other thing I would say, is that Bach's instincts regarding what the late British Prime Minister Harold Macmillan once alluded to as "events, dear boy, events" have so far been sound.

Thomas Bach has faced some controversies in his first year, particularly the Winter Olympics in Sochi, an event closely associated with Russian President Vladimir Putin ©AFP/Getty ImagesThomas Bach has faced some controversies in his first year, particularly the Winter Olympics in Sochi, an event closely associated with Russian President Vladimir Putin
©AFP/Getty Images


He struck the right tone over the various controversies relating to the fact that this year's Winter Olympics were staged in Vladimir Putin's Russia, and seems in recent months to have damped down very considerable fears over the rate of progress in preparations for Rio 2016.

He has presided over a marked improvement in relations between the IOC and the United States, while appearing to do what he can to encourage other potential bidders for the 2024 Summer Games that the US seems to covet.

I think the high priority he appears to be giving to the establishment of an Olympic TV channel is also sensible.

For the rest - most notably the consequences of his Olympic Agenda 2020 reform process - it is just too early to say.

Encouragingly, what might have been a dauntingly complex process has so far been choreographed adroitly yet inclusively.

Much the most taxing period, however, will be the next three months, as key proposals are distilled then put up for approval by IOC members.

Will sensible improvements in areas such as the bidding process and the choice of sporting programme be made?

It will be fascinating to see: given his sure-footed start, you wouldn't bet against Bach navigating a path through the maze; but so many vested interests are in play that enacting a cohesive and game-changing set of reforms will not be easy.

I can't help thinking it is a pity that this bridge wasn't crossed a few years ago, while the Olympic horizon was blissfully trouble-free.

One reason for saying this is that I sense that the sheer jam-packed crowdedness of Bach's first year programme has contributed to what has seemed to me a rather flat-footed response to the lack of love for the Olympics - for the idea of hosting them at any rate - being displayed in a number of affluent West European cities, in particular oil-rich Oslo.

In my discussions on the subject, Olympic leaders have seemed surprised and genuinely puzzled by the depth and extent of antipathy and scepticism that has set in.

Olympic Agenda 2020 should enable them to formulate a general response to the problem, but may have hampered the prompt concoction of a specific one.

Yes, more flexibility in bidding criteria and the IOC's demands may help, but I fear an effective response may have to delve deeper than that, perhaps embracing reforms to the marketing restrictions that have helped secure the Movement's finances, but contribute to local people and businesses feeling estranged from 'their' events.

Thomas Bach has taken encouraging steps to re-engage the Olympic Movement with the world's youth ©Nanjing 2014Thomas Bach has taken encouraging steps to re-engage the Olympic Movement with the world's youth ©Nanjing 2014

There are other big issues too which, while a mere sports body has no obligation to grapple with, you would like to think - given that Bach has met, we are told, 81 heads of state and government already - that the IOC would want to make some sort of contribution to tackling.

Could the Movement do more to prevent the radicalisation of young Muslims?

That, admittedly, is a hugely tall order, but sport ought, you feel, to be part of the solution to such pressing world problems if it is to merit the value its leaders clearly feel it deserves.

Closer to home, has the Movement got the balance right between allowing rich and powerful nations to wallow in conspicuous Olympic, and Paralympic, success and helping athletes from weak, impoverished countries overcome odds that inevitably are stacked against them?

Could it do more to combat obesity?

One could go on.

So, as excellent a start as Bach has made - and I wouldn't be surprised if some in Lausanne have been a little taken aback at the workload - there is still plenty more to do, or at least, that could be done.

Yes, the football-loving former fencer has scored early points, but four years in - halfway through his initial term - will be the time to pass meaningful judgement.

David Owen worked for 20 years for the Financial Times in the United States, Canada, France and the UK. He ended his FT career as sports editor after the 2006 World Cup and is now freelancing, including covering the 2008 Beijing Olympics, the 2010 World Cup and London 2012. Owen's Twitter feed can be accessed here.

Alan Hubbard: Boxing's reformist CK Wu is still the man

Alan HubbardUsually when you learn that sport's long-in-the-tooth heads of state are declining to abdicate gracefully it's a head-in-the-hands groaning situation. Sepp Blatter is a case in point. He steadfastly refuses to hang up his blazer, clinging on to power at his FIFA fiefdom with much of the football world silently mouthing: "For God's sake go! Give someone else a chance."

But no. The Swiss septuagenarian has declared that he will stand for a fifth term of office, which surely means more of the same suaveness and subterfuge for another four years.

So it is with many other sports leaders, who, unlike United States or International Olympic Committee (IOC) Presidents do not have a fixed term in which they must do their job and bow out for better or worse. Instead the old buffers outstay their welcome, frustrating those with the youth, ambition and talent to impose fresh ideas.

Yet there can be the odd exception. And one of them I believe, Dr CK Wu, who, as insidethegames has revealed, is to stand for a third term as President of the International Boxing Association (AIBA).

Now it may surprise you to hear that this is something I heartily applaud. For one good reason. There is no-one better-equipped to continue the reformist work of the 67-year-old Taiwanese architect who has  successfully spruced up a sport which not so long ago was in danger of being ko'd from the Games programme because of a prevailing undercurrent of corruption and sleaze.

AIBA President CK Wu is best equipped to press on with reforming the organisation ©AFP/Getty ImagesAIBA President CK Wu is best equipped to press on with reforming the organisation ©AFP/Getty Images



Yes, I have disagreed vehemently here with Dr Wu on occasions, most notably over his frankly unattainable desire to become the pooh-bah of boxing, bringing even the professional side of the sport into his domain.

I said it could never happen and I believe Dr Wu privately now realises that too. It remains an impossible dream

Instead he now seems wisely to be concentrating on continuing to modernise and "professionalise" what used to be among the most intransigently archaic of sports, the last in the Olympic Movement to actually remove the word "amateur" as a prefix.

Since taking over in 2006 from Pakistan's Anwar Chowdhry, subsequently barred for life by AIBA, he has done an outstanding job, culminating in the formation of two major entities, the international city-franchised, World Series Boxing and soon-to-be launched AIBA Pro Boxing, tournaments in which boxers fight as professionals (i.e. they get paid purse money) while being allowed to retain eligibility to take part in the Olympics.

There is no doubt that Dr Wu once envisaged that this might be a body blow to the real world of professional boxing by encouraging a move under one umbrella. But this has not proved remotely possible.

There is no way AIBA can logically embrace the likes of mega-promoters like Don King, Biob Arum, Frank Warren and Eddie Hearn or fighters including Floyd Mayweather Jnr or Wladimir Klitschko; nor is it feasible they would ever financially or administratively oversee huge promotions such as the record-busting return between Carl Froch and George Groves at Wembley, or have world class pros (e.g. Klitschko and Manny Pacquiao) fighting in an Olympic tournament against comparative novices.

That's pugilistic pie in the sky. Not only unfair but dangerously unhealthy.

Nor, despite the appointment of high-flyer David Gough (ex-IMG and Coca-Cola) as chief executive for its new global marketing company, the Boxing Marketing Arm, will AIBA be able to offer the sort of riches that lured away the two outstanding 2012 Olympic champions, British super-heavyweight Anthony Joshua and Ukraine's Vasyl Lomachenko, now world champion in only his third pro fight.

No, Dr Wu and his cornermen surely will concentrate on what they do best - re-invigorating and enhancing their own brand of the noble art as an attractive spectacle for fighters and fans alike.

The introduction of women's boxing to the Olympic Games is among CK Wu's greatest achievements ©AFP/Getty ImagesThe introduction of women's boxing to the Olympic Games is among CK Wu's greatest achievements ©AFP/Getty Images



Among the most welcome reforms already introduced under the aegis of Dr Wu is the admission of women into the Olympic and World Championship boxing ring, something for which I have long campaigned. The debut of female fighters was one of the high points of London 2012, with the effervescent Nicola Adams becoming the first Olympic gold medallist among the ladies who punch, and subsequently a national icon.

Dr Wu says AIBA's immediate task is to find a way of giving even greater equality to women by opening up more weight categories in which they can compete at Olympic level.

Currently there is provision only for flyweight, lightweight and middleweight. Dr Wu acknowledges that this will not be easy because there would be resistance to sacrificing some of the men's divisions to accommodate more women.

But as an IOC Executive Board member and former Presidential candidate, he can be influential in any re-examination of Olympic quotas across the board in all sports to keep numbers within IOC limits.

Another plus for Dr Wu is that under his aegis there hasn't been a doping scandal or a serious injury in Olympic boxing, now well and truly cemented in the Games programme.

Scandalously biased - and occasionally bent - judging is now far less likely to cause controversy under a rigorous supervisory system. And the adopted 10 points per round pro-style scoring, and refereeing that is far less fussy, with bouts no longer stopped at the first hint of a nosebleed, are welcome innovations.

The jury may still be out on the removal of headguards for men (keeping them for women suggests fear of a reaction to seeing feminine facial damage), but I am personally in favour as there is no conclusive evidence that they prevent eye or head injuries to any great extent.

It seems appropriate in view of his pioneering encouragement of women's boxing that Dr Wu should be up for re-election at the AIBA Congress being held alongside the women's world championships in Jeju Island, South Korea, on November 14.

In view of what the doctor has ordered to keep the sport in such good health, here's wishing him a happy return with the hope he continues to come out fighting.

Alan Hubbard is an award-winning sports columnist for The Independent on Sunday and a former sports editor of The Observer. He has covered a total of 16 Summer and Winter Games, 10 Commonwealth Games, several football World Cups and world title fights from Atlanta to Zaire.

Nick Butler: Archery focused on the big picture after innovative World Cup Final weekend

Nick Butler
Nick ButlerFrom Katniss to Princess Merida, via Legolas, Robin Hood and Green Arrow, it is fair to say that few other sports boast as large a big screen presence as archery.

While the sport in a competitive sense is slightly different to its Hollywood portrayal, there is no doubt that reaching out to people familiar with bow and arrows from the movies is an obvious marketing strategy for the sport's governing body, World Archery.

In an age of reform in the Olympic Movement, where making your sport stand-out is more important than ever, this is archery's unique selling point. Its golden arrow destined for the target.

Turnout at the Vegas Shoot in February, the world's largest indoor tournament that is held alongside the Las Vegas World Archery Indoor World Cup, suggests this is already happening, with a record number of 2,200 archers registering for this year's event with the highest proportion coming from younger age categories.

So in the oh-so-often uttered words of International Olympic Committee (IOC) President Thomas Bach, this is a way of boosting participation levels and "getting the couch potatoes off the couch". Even if watching films on the couch may have got them interested in the first place...

Although he came perilously close to squirming when the question of a quiz, currently doing the rounds on the internet, entitled "Which Hollywood archer are you?" was raised - I came out as "The Avengers" character Hawkeye, for the record - World Archery President Uğur Erdener also admits this is a strong way to boost the image of the sport.

"If Hollywood shortly uses some archery details and arguments, then it is good for my sports popularity," he told insidethegames. "Because, after watching something on film or in a television series, we have an increased number of new athletes."

"It is good for our popularity and, indirectly, for our attractiveness."

Making use of the profile generated by bow and arrow clad Hollywood star such as Hawkeye could bring new people into the sport ©WikipediaMaking use of the profile generated by bow and arrow clad Hollywood star such as Hawkeye could bring new people into the sport ©Wikipedia



In a more general sense, increasing this "attractiveness" is the major target for the sport, and this has been best illustrated by a large number of innovations introduced in recent years, in a structural, technological and marketing sense.

This includes state-of-the-art tablets with apps that enable to you watch the action as it happens, on a choice of four screens, as well as target and overhead cameras and remote controlled robots to collect arrows. Social media is also key, with World Archery celebrating the fact that they had passed 100,000 Facebook likes over the course of this weekend.

"As President Bach showed us in Nanjing [at the Summer Youth Olympic Games], communication technologies are very important for all sports in the Olympic programme," said Erdener, before explaining how his sport is leading the way.

"Archery is a real combined sport - with tradition, history, elegance, precision, integrity, timing, concentration - so many things but attractiveness is the most important part of this.

"We need new and very attractive mobile applications, and we have a young team constantly looking for new ways and new kinds of issues. We have to be more interesting, especially for youngsters. Television interest is also continuously increasing, as is media coverage.

"There is also the World Archery Excellence Centre, which will be built in the next two years in Lausanne, which will be another wonderful opportunity. 

"One of the best examples was at the London 2012 Olympic Games, when, according to all survey results, archery was one of the most popular sports, with satisfaction more than 90 per cent."

If the World Cup Final in Lausanne last weekend was anything to go by, they are finding a strong balance between these innovative elements and more traditional aspects.

The World Cup Final in sunny Lausanne was another strong advertisement for the sport ©Getty ImagesThe World Cup Final in sunny Lausanne was another strong advertisement for the sport ©Getty Images



Held in scorching conditions on a makeshift "field" just a well-aimed arrow away from boats sailing past on Lake Geneva, the choice of setting followed in the footsteps of other recent iconic locations, from Lords Cricket Ground for London 2012 to underneath the Eiffel Tower in Paris for the 2013 World Cup Final.

Like virtually every other sport, music between shots is one of these new editions, and, while I am not sure if Britney Spears' "Baby One More Time" at such a crucial point in the men's recurve final was really necessary, there is no doubt this boosts excitement level. This was blended with Archie the mascot, match commentators in English and French, and more traditional entertainment in the shape of an "Alpine Horns" musical ensemble.

Changes in the match format have also occurred, with a best of five-set system introduced into the Olympic recurve category increasing unpredictability and meaning a far higher proportion of matches end in a shootoff,

In comparison, the format in the more accurate compound division remains a simple highest-score-after-15 arrows-wins format. With the even-higher standard of shooting meaning a single sub-par shot could effectively cost you the match, this reminded me of Twenty20 cricket to recurve's, albeit still fairly rapid, Test format. The principal problem with this analogy being that, in contrast to the cricketing events, it is the compound event which attracts the purists and recurve which reaches out more to the masses.

Given the IOC's current reluctance to add new disciplines within existing sports, it is unlikely the compound bow will be added to the Olympic programme in the short or medium term, but this is the ultimate aim. And featuring for the first time at an Asian Games in Incheon later this month will provide another step forward, with addition to the programme for a future European Games another more realistic target.

But, because it could be added without requiring any more participants, it is hoped the mixed team recurve competition will soon be showcased on the biggest stage.

"Mixed team is one of our important ideas," Erdener told insidethegames. "We tried it at the first version of the Youth Olympics in Singapore, and, after having very good results and input, it was held again in Nanjing.

"We have proposed this category to the IOC for inclusion in Tokyo 2020, and expect that it will bring more attractiveness to the Olympic programme.

"It is another opportunity for good communication between athletes."

Given the fact that the Swiss hosts were resolutely swept aside by a world-class Mexican outfit in Lausanne, the mixed team competition was something of a damp squib. But it worth noting that IOC President Thomas Bach arrived to watch just in time to catch the mixed team final, and, once again, it is a concept firmly in line with the current zeitgeist in IOC circles.

World Archery President Uğur Erdener and IOC boss Thomas Bach watching the archery ©World ArcheryWorld Archery President Uğur Erdener and IOC boss Thomas Bach watching the archery ©World Archery



Given that he is also a member of the IOC's ruling Executive Board and the chair of the IOC Medical Commission, not to mention the Turkish Olympic Committee chief and a prominent member of both the World Anti Doping Agency and the Association of Summer Olympic International Federations, having Dr Erdener at the helm of the sport is a major boost.

But there are other challenges for the sport looking forward. Although the attendance in Lausanne was impressive, particularly for the final session in which recurve finals took place, for all the good promotional work, more needs to be done to compete with spectator-levels in the biggest Olympic sports. Growth in Africa appears another obvious aspiration, particularly because, in comparison with some sports, the equipment and facilities required are relatively limited.

But the success for Colombia, Mexico and Brazil shows a sport this is reaching out into new regions, and in Marcus D'Almeida, the recurve second place finisher in Lausanne, the sport has an arguably even greater icon than any Hollywood archer could provide.

The 16-year-old is a talent of meteoric proportions, already meriting the label in his native Brazil of "archery's Neymar". But he is also a great ambassador for the sport-in-the-making globally, and if he is to win on home turf at Rio 2016, he could very well be the first archery mega-star.

His recent fortunes and strong prospects can be taken as a mirror for the sport as a whole, looking ahead first to the outcome of Olympic Agenda 2020, then to the next year's World Cup Series culminating in the Final in Mexico City, and then Rio 2016.

And by that point, it is possible a new generation of Hunger Games and The Avengers loving enthusiasts may have been inspired into the sport, taking it to even greater heights.

Nick Butler is a reporter for insidethegames. To follow him on Twitter click here.

Emily Goddard: Bringing the Commonwealth Games back to Edmonton with a bit of Canadian charm

Emily Goddard
Emily GoddardThere is a stereotype that Canadians are a thoroughly nice bunch of people. If Edmonton 2022's dreams are anything to go by, it is most likely true.

The team bidding to host the Commonwealth Games in eight years' time has a vision that each of the 71 nations that will compete at the event will take home at least one medal of any colour.

How nice is that?

At first glance, it appears to be a wildly optimistic goal, particularly as 19 countries and territories have competed at the Commonwealth Games and never won a medal, but Edmonton 2022 has already thought about how to achieve this in some depth.

Speaking at a press briefing in London on Tuesday (September 2) to mark the one-year countdown to the date when the Commonwealth Games Federation (CGF) will announce the 2022 host city at its General Assembly in Auckland, New Zealand, Edmonton 2022 chairman Reg Milley unveiled plans for a dedicated Commonwealth Games sporting excellence centre in Edmonton for all nations.

The facility will offer high performance training on campus as well as advice through an online system. The basic theory behind the project cannot be knocked but the logistics are something that need to be examined to assess its feasibility.

With about only 40 per cent of the world's population having an internet connection today, that still leaves a majority without it and therefore unable to access any online training. There is also the cost of travel and flights for nations wanting to visit the centre for training. Milley admits there is still work to be done but hopes to overcome such obstacles through partnerships with both the public and private firms.

Edmonton last hosted the Commonwealth Games in 1978 ©Getty ImagesEdmonton last hosted the Commonwealth Games in 1978 ©Getty Images



"Do we get companies that would set up an endowment fund, for example, to help the smaller countries participating?" he said. "Do we partner with communications companies to be able to do this online project so they can get involved and help make it so that there is computer access in those places? We think that by the creation of the centre we will be able to move people in and be able to work with them to develop techniques for training.

"There's ways that we can make this happen either through endowment funding or through sports funding. We think we can help with that. We could bring countries together in a central location and provide expertise. We believe we can deliver this so that all 71 nations do become more competitive."

There is also, however, the question of large and already successful sporting nations taking advantage of the facility to increase their chances of dominating the podium places, but Milley envisages that this will not be a problem.

"I see a lot of the larger countries, with funds accessing their own high performance centres," he said.

"What we want to do is create an environment whereby some of those countries that can't do it will do it. I think some of the bigger countries will take advantage of it but if everybody has the same level playing field we can expose smaller countries to it as well as the Australias and the Canadas."

Reg Milley said Edmonton 2022 is keen to support smaller nations to help them achieve their medal winning dreams ©City of EdmontonReg Milley said Edmonton 2022 is keen to support smaller nations to help them achieve their medal winning dreams ©City of Edmonton


Asked about his views on the anti-gay laws in the more than 40 Commonwealth member countries - these criminalise homosexuality and seven of the nations have a maximum penalty of life imprisonment, Milley made it clear that all those attending the Games, should they take place in Edmonton in 2022, would be welcome regardless of their race, religion, gender or sexual orientation.

"Our city is a great believer in equality and when I look at the three major thrusts and the values of the Commonwealth Games, with humanity, equality and destiny, I see that you've got to get there [achieving equality]," he told me. "Some of us are getting there faster than others, but I believe we will eventually all get there. I honestly believe we will. It's the same thing as you see with gender in sport. We are getting better and better all the time and we will get better at this as well.

"There are always differences so what we need to do is to help look at these and work with people and say how can we be better? But these are policy decisions that need to be made by these countries. If I could wave a magic wand and do it, it would be very different but I can't. It is crucial [to create a culture where there is no fear of attending a Games].

"The only stress that we want the athletes to be under at the Games in 2022 is the stress of competition. We don't want any other stresses. None. So we'll be working our hardest to make sure there are none of those stresses."

Edmonton already has a whole host of international standard sports facilities, including the Commonwealth Stadium ©Getty ImagesEdmonton already has a whole host of international standard sports facilities, including the Commonwealth Stadium ©Getty Images



So does being nice mean you won't get anywhere in this dog eat dog world? Edmonton appears a good choice for the CGF. The city has a lot going for it. It has a stable economy, a strong sporting heritage, a whole host of international standard sports facilities, a sound infrastructure network and it is a safe pair of hands having hosted the Commonwealth Games in 1978.

But Milley is very aware of the particularly strong challenge presented by Durban - another potentially excellent host with much experience of staging major events.

"Durban is going to be a formidable opponent and we are going to have to be at the top of our game," he admitted. "Can they do it? Yes, they can. But to us it's not about who can host the Games, it's about who can move the Games further ahead, who can do more relevancy with the Games. When you think about it, there are really only two icons of the Games - there's the Monarchy and the Games.

"So how do we keep both relevant? We've got to do more to move the Commonwealth forward. We are in the ideal position to do that and we are totally focused on these Games. It's not about doing anything else, it's these Games. This is our future."

Emily Goddard is a reporter and subeditor at insidethegames.biz. To follow her on Twitter click here.

Mike Rowbottom: FIVB lights up the field of sport with a net gain

Mike Rowbottom
Mike Rowbottom ©insidethegamesNo expense was spared within the VIP section at Warsaw's Stadion Narodowy on Saturday night as the great and good of the world volleyball scene witnessed a hugely ambitious Opening Ceremony for the FIVB World Championships that was followed by a stirring 3-0 win for the host nation over Serbia, their most dangerous opponents in the opening group matches.

Security on the door was tight. At one point my bread and cheese selection came under heavy scrutiny. In retrospect I should never have taken it out of the room, but having done so I became stubbornly attached to it. Happily the blameless platter was allowed to pass. But you could understand the jitters - after all, there was the Polish President present.

Inside this enclave of privilege, heavily made-up young hostesses of alarming height and depressing thinness smiled and...well, that was the only thing I can remember them doing in fact. Huge vases of deep red flowers were lit at intervals by pools of golden light, thus echoing the predominant colours of marketing for the event, with red symbolising the passion Poland's people have for a sport which, in physical terms, resembles a sequence of unfeasibly prolonged conversations.

Polish fans enjoyed a massive spectacle of Opening Ceremony and home victory as the World Volleyball Championships got underway in Warsaw on Saturday night ©Getty ImagesPolish fans enjoyed a massive spectacle of Opening Ceremony and home victory as the World Volleyball Championships got underway in Warsaw on Saturday night ©Getty Images

Within the main body of a stadium built initially to host Euro 2012 football matches, a 70,000 crowd (62,000 plus 8,000 guests/media, tickets sold out in May) was encouraged to participate at all relevant points by a smiling MC and his keyboard-playing mate up in the stands. For the VIPs, drifting over to the windows or the open doors to witness the ferment, champagne in hand, the whole spectacle was immensely diverting.

But how many of them, you wondered, fully realised the significance of a display set up at the far end of the room - a full-sized volleyball net, but a net with a dazzling difference - a net which came periodically alive with lights of all colours and gliding words thanks to hundreds of small but very sturdy LED lights woven into the design?

That was a rhetorical question of course, although the answer would probably be: not many.

Had they asked Michael Payne, the sports marketing guru currently advising the effervescent, recently ensconced President of the International Volleyball Federation (FIVB) Dr. Ary Graça as he seeks to renovate and re-energise the sport, they would have been in no doubt. This glowing, fizzing, flowing net was a "game changer".

A new net currently being pioneered could revolutionise volleyball, it is predicted ©ITGA new net currently being pioneered could revolutionise volleyball, it is predicted ©ITG

Let Payne explain.

"At the London 2012 Olympics, beach volleyball was pushing the entertainment levels, and if anything indoor volleyball was lagging behind," he said. "The sport was in danger of becoming polarised. So this development is a game changer for the sport in terms of field of play."

Graça, too, is enthused by the new possibilities opening up in the field of play.

"For example, one player spikes, the other blocks," said Graça in characteristically animated fashion. "When the ball falls, you are going to see 'Block!...Block!...Block!...Block!' on the net.

"Or maybe you can use it for information, everything about the players. Or in the gap between two sets, you can use it as a commercial, as a merchandising tool."

Polish players rise to block a Serbian spike in the opening match of the World Championships. In future years, the net between the players could become something of a player itself ©Getty ImagesPolish players rise to block a Serbian spike in the opening match of the World Championships. In future years, the net between the players could become something of a player itself
©Getty Images


The net could be put to yet other uses. After the President had explained how the FIVB has brought in a rule requiring a serve to be made no later than eight seconds after the ball has been grounded, he mooted the idea of having the net blank on the receiver's side, but offering a graphic countdown on the side of the server.

"FIFA could learn from that," observed someone sagely. "The time taken by goalkeepers..."

It is certainly an intriguing proposition.

"Over the next few months it will be taken into sporting competition and the Federation will begin to work out the rules of when the net is used as a presentation for the sport, and when it is used as a in a commercial way," said Payne. "We need to work out a new protocol."

Mike Rowbottom captured at the Stadion Narodowy without his bread and cheese selection and flute of champagne ©ITGMike Rowbottom captured at the Stadion Narodowy, unusually, without his bread and cheese selection and flute of champagne ©ITG

On the night, however, the proud inventors of this new toy were happy to see it scan blameless slogans and messages across its twinkling frontage. The word 'volleyball' slid across, flashing white. Who would argue with that?

Given the location, however, the gliding messages should more usefully have read: "That's your fourth glass!", "Nice canapé action!" or "She's still not interested in you!"

Who knows, similar technology might also be adopted in other sports with nets. One could imagine a message sliding across the rigging inside Wimbledon's Centre Court, for instance: "Mr Nadal, you have eight seconds in which to serve, seven, six, five, four..."

I'm sure Mr Nadal would be thrilled to have such a useful reminder in front of him at all times.

Mike Rowbottom, one of Britain's most talented sportswriters, covered the London 2012 Olympics and Paralympics as chief feature writer for insidethegames, having covered the previous five summer Games, and four winter Games, for The Independent. He has worked for the Daily Mail, The Times, The Observer, The Sunday Correspondent and The Guardian. His latest book Foul Play – the Dark Arts of Cheating in Sport (Bloomsbury £8.99) is available at the insidethegames.biz shop. To follow him on Twitter click here.

David Owen: Strava - taking the loneliness out of long distance running

David OwenThe Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner is one of those great 1960s British films that tackle edgy social themes, in this case the life of a young petty thief who discovers a talent for running.

But lonely runners, and for that matter cyclists, may soon be a thing of the past, if a business called Strava continues to grow.

Strava, the Swedish word for "to strive", was founded five years ago by two former Harvard oarsmen, Mark Gainey and Michael Horvath.

Having set up one software company and taken it public, the pair found themselves as middle-aged family men with the sort of obligations that made team-sports impractical.

It was out of this situation that the idea for Strava arose; as Gareth Nettleton, the business's London-based director of international marketing, explained: "They saw software as a platform that would allow them to create some social competition, authentic camaraderie and in-depth training tools.

"In its simplest form, they imagined a 'virtual locker-room' where they could share workouts among their athlete friends and keep each other motivated along the way."

The idea has grown into a service that enables millions of potentially solitary recreational runners and cyclists around the world to interreact with each other.

Strava allows runners and cyclists around the world to connect with each other ©StravaStrava allows runners and cyclists around the world to connect with each other ©Strava



Peter Keen, the enormously successful former performance director of UK Sport who alerted me to Strava's existence, thinks it is "a game-changer.

"It's turning an individual activity into a social sport," he says.

According to Nettleton, Strava is easy to join, either by signing up free of charge on the Strava.com website, or by downloading a mobile app.

He continues: "When a member goes for a run or a ride, Strava will help them track their activity.

"They can do this by using the Strava app on their smart-phone, or they can run or ride with pretty much any other GPS device, such as a watch or bike computer, and upload to the Strava website afterwards.

"Once a member uploads, we analyse their data to show them where they ran or rode, how fast they went and how hard they were working.

"Additionally, we also allow our members to compare their times with other runners and cyclists who have run or ridden the same roads and trails previously.

"We call these Strava segments."

Keen, now director of sport advancement and strategy at Loughborough University in the English Midlands, says: "You can see a complete record of your day in the saddle and social interaction is built-in.

"People are, in effect, racing each other by recording their performance over a given section of road.

"You can tell you are, say, 10th out of 12,000.

"It's changing the nature of cycling."

The fastest athletes over individual segments are awarded "King of the Mountains" or "Course Record" accolades.

Gareth Nettleton, Strava's London-based director of international marketing, has said the business has changed the nature of cycling ©Gareth Nettleton/TwitterGareth Nettleton, Strava's London-based director of international marketing, has said the business has changed the nature of cycling ©Gareth Nettleton/Twitter



"The competition is a real motivator," Nettleton says.

He also explains that Strava has a popular "Clubs" section, which he likens to "virtual clubhouses where announcements get made, group runs and rides get organised and important notices get posted.

"We have seen real-world clubs setting up their own Strava club as an extension of what they have already, as well as entirely virtual clubs springing up, where running and riding buddies can keep track of each other even if they are based on opposite sides of the globe," he says.

How does San Francisco-based Strava make money, given that no advertising was, as Nettleton puts it, "a founding principle"?

He says the business model is a subscription one: "We have Strava Premium, which costs $3.99 (£2.42/€3.03) per month or $39.99 (£24.30/€30.44) for an annual subscription".

This offers a "richer" Strava experience with additional features and functionality which allow more detailed analysis of performance.

The business also offers what Nettleton describes as a "fairly unique e-commerce platform and model.

"Every month, we run certain challenges on Strava and for those athletes who successfully complete a challenge, we make unique gear rewards available for them to purchase.

"This could be a one-off cycling jersey for instance that will only be available to those athletes who put in the hard work to complete the challenge."

Data on where people run and ride is being made available to transport departments and town planners ©Getty ImagesData on where people run and ride is being made available to transport departments and town planners ©Getty Images



Finally, anonymised data on where people run and ride is offered to transport departments and town planners through the Strava Metro service.

"In the UK, we have recently started working with Transport for London and Glasgow City Council," Nettleton says.

"It's the kind of information they can't get from anywhere else."

Could Strava branch out into other sports - triathlon seems the most obvious, since it caters for two of the three disciplines already?

For now, Nettleton tells me, it is concentrating on runners and cyclists primarily, though he acknowledges "serving triathletes is an obvious next step, and in fact we already allow members to upload their swims if they have a device that can track them".

For the foreseeable future, however, he says, the business's "energies will be spent on continually improving and enhancing the Strava experience for the members that we already have".

Someone once said that the internet meant the death of geography.

By applying that insight to sport, while enabling recreational athletes to feel part of a team without sacrificing the freedom to exercise when, where and how it suits them, Strava seems to have devised a service that is very well adapted to the realities of modern life.

David Owen worked for 20 years for the Financial Times in the United States, Canada, France and the UK. He ended his FT career as sports editor after the 2006 World Cup and is now freelancing, including covering the 2008 Beijing Olympics, the 2010 World Cup and London 2012. Owen's Twitter feed can be accessed here.