Alan Hubbard: Sport needs to tackle racism but the PC police should keep their noses out

Duncan Mackay
Alan HubbardRacism has long been the most reviled word in the sporting lexicon, ranking alongside only its six-letter companion, doping, in the opprobrium it engenders.

We had hoped by now it would have been eradicated, but if you believe all you glean from the papers or the box, this is far from the case.

Fortunately these days racism rarely touches the Olympic Games, and hasn't since the day the International Olympic Committee finally got the message Tommie Smith and John Carlos were sending out and removed then apartheid South Africa from the Games.

But it certainly prevails in other sporting environments, not least football where there is a scandalous paucity of black coaches and managers.Now we have a lingering controversy over England manager Roy Hodgson's believably innocent but bafflingly naive "monkey" dressing room reference to new boy Andros Townsend.

This was compounded by Football Association chairman Greg Dyke's initial decision to rely on blue blazers rather than a black presence in his commission set up to examine at the future structure of English football; a misjudgement rightly castigated publicly by the admirable Jamaican-born Heather Rabbatts, the only representative on the FA board of both her sex and ethnicity.

Leaving aside whether the subsequent reaction to both matters has been somewhat OTT - it is good that the situation has propelled the new Sports Minister, Helen Grant, herself of mixed race, to have a sharp word in the ear of the FA to ascertain exactly what is going on in that virtually all-white ivory tower at Wembley.

It may be of some comfort, however, that Britain is not alone in having to deal with problems of supposed discrimination.

Washington Redskins fans often dress up to support their NFL teamWashington Redskins fans often dress up to support their NFL team

Across the Atlantic, one of the current major talking points in Washington is not not the recent crippling Government shut-down, President Obama's health care programme or the threat of terrorism or nuclear war - but whether the Washington Redskins should be made to change their name.

Protest groups have campaigned for years for the removal of the word Redskins, now considered a racial slur.

But the NFL team's owner Dan Snyder has dug in his heels, insising:"It will l never change."

He adds: "The fans have no desire whatsoever to see the team name changed solely because their owners succumbed to political pressure. It's also important to remember that there's a long and proud history surrounding the Washington Redskins that goes back generations, a tradition I imagine most fans won't want to give up."

Polls among Native Americans themselves show a fair degree of ambivalence but a growing number of non-Native Americans, including many media outlets covering the NFL, have begun to question the use of the term. Some even refuse to use it, referring to the team simply as Washington.

The debate is ongoing, and there has been a noticeable surge in momentum with President Obama saying last month he would think about changing the name if he owned the Redskins.

Many civil rights, educational, athletic, and academic organisations consider any use of native names and symbols a harmful form of ethnic stereotyping while others believe it honours the achievements and virtues of Native Americans, and that it is not intended in a negative manner.

Former Redskins owner Jack Kent-Cooke has said: "I admire the Redskins name. I think it stands for bravery, courage, and a stalwart spirit and I see no reason why we shouldn't continue to use it."

The Washington Redskins were originally known as the Boston Braves but changed to the Redskins after relocating to the nation's capital in 1937, possibly in recognition of the then–head coach Lone Star Dietz, whom claimed to be part Sioux.

The unofficial mascot of the team is actually an African-American, Zema Williams (aka Chief Zee) who has attended games since 1978 dressed in a "Red Indian" costume complete with feathered war bonnet and tomahawk. It is not unusual for other fans to turn up in similar guise.

Any reference to Indians now taboo in the United States. Hollywood hasn't dared make a proper cowboys and Indians film for decades because of the offence it might cause among the Native American minority.

Even sport can't get in on that traditional confrontation. America has the Dallas Cowboys and the Cleveland Indians but the former is a football team and the latter a baseball franchise.

Like the Cleveland Indians, the Atlanta Braves and the Kansas City Chiefs, many college and professional teams draw on an Indian theme for their names.

However Cleveland have been heavily criticised for their logo, one Chief Wahoo, while the "Tomahawk Chop" hand gesture used by Atlanta Braves' fans has also been under fire for allegedly causing offence.

The "Tomahawk Chop", a regular favourite of Atlanta Braves supporters, is under fire from the PC policeThe "Tomahawk Chop", a regular favourite of Atlanta Braves supporters, is under fire from the PC police

Might this form of political correctness now spread to Britain, where where rugby union's Exeter Chiefs are supported by young fans who adorn themselves in splendidly colourful Indian headdresses. The Devon club's logo is also an Indian chief.

Name changes are not uncommon in America, particularly when franchises change hands, and cities. The Los Angeles Dodgers began as then Brooklyn Grays and this season sees the debut of the New Orleans Pelicans (formerly Hornets) in the NBA.

And in Washington the capital's basketball team switched from the Bullets to the Wizards over the rise of gun violence.

I have long had misgivings about how much longer the New Zealand rugby team will be permitted to label themselves the All-Blacks. And one fears for those football clubs such at Tottenham Hotspur, Bolton Wanderers and Preston North End whose original white shirts earned them the sobriquet of "The Lillywhites".

Back in Britain we sometimes wonder whether our sporting world has gone bonkers by succumbing to so much nonsensical political correctness.

For example, the former England and Liverpool striker Robbie Fowler player had to apologise via the BBC for remarking that players involved in a handbags-at-ten-paces confrontation were "fighting like schoolgirls". It was perceived to be sexist.

Even if he had instead said "they were fighting like kids in a playground" no doubt he would have had the Child Protection Agency on his case.

ITV presenter Adrian Chiles was forced to apologise following a joke he made about Polish builders at the end of an England football internationalITV presenter Adrian Chiles was forced to apologise following a joke he made about Polish builders at the end of an England football international

Equally fatuous was the chiding of ITV football presenter Adrian Chiles' over his "Polish joke" during the channel's coverage of England's 4-1 World Cup victory over Montenegro. Chiles started to look forward to England's clash with Poland which, said Chiles - whose mother is Croatian - was "practically a home game for Poland - 15,000 Poles will be in here, I'm sure."

Pundit Lee Dixon responded by saying: "Hopefully, they're all crying at the end," to which Chiles replied: "I'm trying to get some building work done at the moment, quite seriously. Be careful."

That was deemed to be seriously offensive yet I bet most Polish builders fell about laughing. And why not? The joke, surely was on the charmless, humourless PC police who seem hellbent on imposing their po-faced will on sport.

Sport needs to tackle actual racism and prejudice, rather than waste time on such pettifogging nonsense.

Meantime in the White House a black President takes time out to address the issue of whether the Washington Redskins should be forced to become the Washington Native Americans.

And this in The Home Of The Brave.

Alan Hubbard is a sports columnist for the The Independent on Sunday, and a former sports editor of The Observer. He has covered a total of 16 Summer and Winter Games, 10 Commonwealth Games, several football World Cups and world title fights from Atlanta to Zaire.

Nick Butler: Beyond Duchesses and University Challenge, "inspiring a generation" was in full force again in London

Nick Butler
Nick Butler Olympic Stadium 2 July 24 2013 1Notwithstanding the air miles, rail fares and almost constant visits to coffee shops to bask in the comforts of complimentary Wi-Fi, my first three months at insidethegames have been dictated most of all by two words beginning with "L" in "London 2012" and "legacy".

The road in pursuit of these dual themes has ranged from the glamorous - Anniversary Games athletics and Grand Final triathlon - to the more intense in City Hall where two members of the London Legacy Development Corporation were put to the sword by the London Assembly Regeneration Committee.

Last Friday (October 18) it was all about the most famous London 2012 Olympic slogan of them all as the relevance of Sebastian Coe's motto "Inspire a Generation" was illustrated by not one, but two, London events. 

First up was a SportsAid workshop at the Copper Box, where young athletes on the cusp of elite level being given logistical support by the charity were on hand to illustrate their fine credentials over five sports: badminton, fencing, wheelchair basketball, volleyball and cerebral palsy football.

In the eyes, or the lenses, of the vast number of snap-happy photographers present the real talking point was the presence of a Royal Patron in the Duchess of Cambridge in her first solo engagement since the birth of Prince George in July.

He is certainly one youngster who, given his several Olympian relations, has fine sporting credentials.

While most of the press pack were bothered most by the the Duchesses clothing choices - in my fashion-conscious eyes a zebra hooped top, cardigan, leggings and platform heels - or her supposedly rapid post-pregnancy weight loss, I preferred the fact that she was so keen to be involved in such a reputable sporting organisation.

This was a point made by the impressive number of SportsAid beneficiaries present, including Olympic champion rowers Katherine Grainger and Steve Williams. Also there was the Athens 2004 bronze medal winning swimmer Steve Parry  - who became arguably more famous four years later, at least in China, when he was repeatedly mistaken for another swimmer, Michael Phelps.

Steve Parry alongside his lookalike Michael Phelps on the medal podium in AthensSteve Parry alongside his lookalike Michael Phelps on the medal podium in Athens...his medal would have been "more of a challenge" without SportsAid


"I myself was the recipient of a SportsAid Grant, and winning my medal would have been much more of a challenge without this support," Parry explained to insidethegames. "My parents were paying for my trains, petrol and hotels otherwise, but to be honest I don't think you can get by without these grants because, although modest, they are absolutely vital.

"Sporting activities cost a boatload of money so it is vital to the fabric of the sporting infrastructure really. SportsAid does a fantastic job  raising money for kids up and down the country. You can see this by the endless people who benefited who want to come down today and get involved. Statistically they are very good at picking people who will turn into the next Olympic champions. The Duchess of Cambridge being a patron of such a fantastic charity is brilliant."

Indeed, the clear excitement of all of the youngsters, particularly those volleyball players who, albeit briefly, shared a court with her, underlined this point perfectly.

Another advantage of the day was that it gave youngsters the chance to partake in new sports as well as their more established ones and this was something Parry also took advantage of. "I'm rubbish at volleyball, not so good at footy, alright at badminton...and a bit of a killer at wheelchair basketball," he summarised.

Unconventional footwear maybe but the Duchess of Cambridge enjoyed trying out volleyball as part of the Sports Aid workshopUnconventional footwear maybe but the Duchess of Cambridge was another keen participant as she tried out volleyball for the first time


The day, yet another legacy event in the Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park, also emphasised the raft of work going on to transform the Park from a home of elite sport to a base for sport at all levels.

This was something explained by Peter Tudor, director of venues at the Olympic Park, in relation to the Copper Box. "For a long time the only people coming here were those with hard hats on doing building work and now its local residents, both young and mature people," he said.

Although he emphasised that they are indeed targeting all age groups, Tudor described a series of other events focusing on youth, ranging from "come and try" events during the October half term and Christmas holidays to a "LolliBop" festival aimed at toddlers held in August.

Not all of these events however are held within the Park and this was illustrated by my second trip of the day which took place down the road, or in my case the Docklands Light Railway, at the University of East London.

Organised by London Youth Rowing as part of Sport England's "Satellite Clubs" programme, this gave an opportunity for youngsters from throughout the city to try their hand at rowing in a competitive sense.

With all the youngsters representing their schools side by side in an tightly packed sportshall, there was a raucous atmosphere filled with suspense and vocal support.

Or at least their apparently was as, faced with the journalistic challenge of a "double event day", I turned up just in time to catch the end of the prize giving, and then the tidying up process...

London youngsters across a huge variety of backgrounds participated in the rowing eventLondon youngsters across a huge variety of backgrounds participated in the London Youth Rowing event


I was, however, in time to speak to some of the participants.

"If you say to friends you do rowing they laugh and call you posh, but its a good sport which people don't know enough about," conceded one. 

There was also another trademark "celebrity" on show in prize presenter Bamber Gascoigne who - while not the Duchess of Cambridge - was still a source of inspiration particularly for those brought up in household where watching University Challenge passed for an essential evening leisure activity.

Gascoigne, a rowing enthusiast but also a graduate who has succeeded well beyond sport, suitably emphasised the point of the event, and of the Satellite Clubs project as a whole.

Beyond the rowing however was a careers fair and the focus was "about seeing sporting participation as one aspect of a wider lifestyle", Mike Diaper, Sport England's director of community sport, told insidethegames.

"We've done studies that if you build sport into your lives it actually helps employability. If you are a sporty person you know teamwork, discipline and leadership and all of those skills are really transferable. Linking the sport to the careers fair is a great way to show these cross over skills."

The project aims is about "transitioning youngsters from school sport,"  Diaper said. "At school everything is free of charge, laid on for you and you often don't even need kit. But even the most sporting youngsters find joining sports clubs a pretty daunting thing so what this programme is doing is bridging the gap."

"We take existing sports clubs and put an outpost on the schools site but it is run by the club and not the school so it doesn't feel like a PE lesson. What they want is something that feels a little bit less like school so they feel in control."

Diaper continued to explain that the scheme is open to all, across 46 different sporting governing bodies and in all regions of England. Many will be disability sport specific and others will be girls only so we will have opportunities for everybody, he added.

With the aim to produce 5,000 clubs by 2017 already 20 per cent successful the success is striking so far

Like with SportsAid, the aim may be to produce elite athletes but most of all it is about allowing youngsters to have greater participation opportunities across a wider platform of sports.

The presence of the likes of the Duchess of Cambridge and Gascoigne, as well as Parry helps to raise the profile but the main focus, as throughout London 2012, concerns youth and, of course, "inspiring a generation".

On the evidence of Friday's doubleheader the wide variety of funding and opportunities being created suggests that many are being suitable inspired and that the London 2012 legacy effect is still succeeding.

Nick Butler is a reporter for insidethegames. To follow him on Twitter click here

Jon Wilkin: Fans have a right to a doping-free Rugby League World Cup

Emily Goddard
Jon WilkinIn May 2010 I was appointed a member of UK Anti-Doping (UKAD)'s newly-formed Athlete Committee. This provided an opportunity for athletes and players such as myself to feed into anti-doping policy and decision making for, like it or not, anti-doping is part and parcel of life in elite sport.

Amidst all the preparations for this month's Rugby League World Cup - the hours of training on the pitch and in the gym - the responsibility to compete clean is constant and essential. Our sport has been under public scrutiny since the Australian Crime Commission report was published back in January, and fans have a right to watch, support, and believe in a doping-free World Cup.

One of the key developments in anti-doping we have seen over the last three years is the use of intelligence to inform programmes through a risk-based approach. Every player coming to compete in the UK this month should be prepared for a stringent anti-doping programme. Through the Athlete Committee, I have learnt firsthand of how such an approach works and how important this approach is to anti-doping. UKAD's Intelligence Team gather all kinds of information and use this to inform their testing and education programmes.

The Win Clean campaign has been working to ensure that all players are made aware of their anti-doping rights and responsibilitiesThe Win Clean campaign has been working to ensure that all players are made aware of their anti-doping rights and responsibilities


The Education team have been working on a bespoke "Win Clean" campaign to ensure that all players are made aware of their anti-doping rights and responsibilities.

It is not enough for players to say "I didn't know" - the principle of strict liability requires every player or athlete, whatever your sport, to take responsibility for what goes into their body. The Athlete Committee has discussed the issue of supplements on a number of occasions, the high number of positives these products cause, and the possible risks to health. Education programmes are in place to raise awareness and help prevent inadvertent doping. Supporting this, UKAD will also work with the coaches, medics, team managers and other key staff supporting teams at the World Cup to ensure they help players to make the most informed decisions when it comes to anti-doping.

I hope we can inspire a few more to take up the sport, and importantly, be encouraged to do so without the temptation of performance-enhancing drugs.

Jon Wilkin is an England international and UKAD Athlete Committee member

Simon Morton: British sport aiming for international success around board table as well as medal table

Duncan Mackay
Simon MortonBrian Cookson's recent election to the Presidency of the International Cycling Union (UCI) is an important moment for British sport.

Whilst the last decade has seen Great Britain secure a strong position on the medals table, it has taken longer for Britain to regain its position around the board table of international sport. There are however encouraging signs that this is starting to change.

Re-building influence in international sport takes time, not least because the top jobs simply don't come around that often.

There have only been two Presidents of FIFA in the last 40 years, and only five Presidents of the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) in its 101-year history. With his successful election last month, Cookson became the first person from this country for over 20 years to be elected as international President of a core summer Olympic sport. The last Briton to lead such a sport was the Princess Royal, who stepped down as President of the International Equestrian Federation (FEI) in 1994.

Brian Cookson's election as President of the International Cycling Union demonstrates Britain's growing influence at the top level of world sportBrian Cookson's election as President of the International Cycling Union demonstrates Britain's growing influence at the top level of world sport

Many have noted the decline in British influence from the previous century when our sports administrators led many International Federations, but a return to those days is neither possible nor desirable. International sport has moved on and the Federations are now much more geographically diverse - a case in point being the 25 current Presidents of the core Summer Olympic sports, who come from 21 different countries.

There are other positive signs that Britain is once again becoming a credible and valued member of the international sporting community. Influence is not just about taking the top positions and, since London 2012, 15 out of 17 British candidates have been successful in securing positions on the Boards of the international governing bodies of their Olympic and Paralympic sports.

Having a strong voice in the international governance of sport is not just about advocating national interests. It is also about helping to make those International Federations as strong and credible as possible. If the public lose faith in the integrity of these international bodies to govern fairly and effectively, then the investment that UK Sport makes into national high performance success and hosting major events is severely compromised.

This is a key reason why UK Sport, working in partnership with the British Olympic Association (BOA) and British Paralympic Association (BPA), is providing support to sport's National Governing Bodies (NGBs) to develop and implement their own international relations strategies.

An important part of UK Sport's support to NGBs is about identifying and developing the next generation of British leaders that can play an active role in their international sporting organisations.

Emma Mason has been elected chair of the Badminton World Federation Athletes’ Commission and is now a member of the governing body's ruling CouncilEmma Mason has been elected chair of the Badminton World Federation Athletes’ Commission and is now a member of the governing body's ruling Council

It is hugely encouraging to see a number of our ex-athletes step forward, and in the last year alone Beth Tweddle has been elected to the Athletes' Commission of International Gymnastics Federation (FIG), Sarah Gosling to the Athletes' Commission of International Sailing Federation (ISAF), Emma Mason to the Council of the Badminton World Federation (BWF), and Sarah Stevenson to the Council of the World Taekwondo Federation (WTF).

We have also recently launched the sixth year of our International Leadership Programme which helps British representatives involved in the international governance of their sports to operate more effectively.

It is great to see some of the alumni from this programme securing key positions that will help shape their sports internationally, such as Chris Atkins elected as vice-president of ISAF, Sue Catton elected onto the Executive Board of the International Hockey Federation (FIH), and, most recently, Martin Gibbs appointed as chief of staff for the UCI.

Simon Morton is director of major events and international relations at UK Sport

Alan Hubbard: Sport needs to stop blowing hot and cold over where it holds its major events

Duncan Mackay
Alan HubbardBack in 1968, just before the start of the Olympic Games in searingly hot, uncomfortably high altitude Mexico City, the late Chris Brasher sounded an ominous warning. "There will be those who die," he thundered in The Observer.

He was right. Some 300 civilians, mainly students protesting about the repressive regime and escalating cost of the Games in a relatively impoverished nation, were infamously massacred by Mexican Government troops in the Plaza of The Three Cultures.

It remains one of the most shameful episodes in Olympic history.

But no-one died during the Games from either the hot air or the thin air, to which Brasher was actually referring.

Brasher's false prediction has come to mind now we have this brouhaha over whether the 2022 football World Cup scheduled for Qatar should be moved either to an inconvenient winter month or even elsewhere because the summer climate in the Gulf state is too hot to handle.

Yet is that really so? Would the conditions be that unbearable for the world's top footballers? Shouldn't these highly-paid professional athletes - many extravagantly so - be sufficiently prepared to cope with any extremes of climate with all the state-of- the age medical and scientific back-up at their disposal?

Surely the rewards and ample enough and their bodies well-honed enough to take the rough with the smooth, the hot with the cold?

Yes, the weather in a Qatar summer is stifling. But so it is in Pakistan, India and parts of Australia and South Africa where Test cricket is played without any beefing about the temperature being in the nineties - or more.

While that daytime summer in Qatar - as in most Middle East nations  can be pretty fierce it is certainly cooler in the evenings when the majority - if not all - the matches would be played in air-cooled stadiums.

Stadiums for the 2022 World Cup in Qatar will all feature state-of-the-art air conditioning systemsStadiums for the 2022 World Cup in Qatar will all feature state-of-the-art air conditioning systems

Indeed, spectatators may find it distinctly chilly in the nether regions when the air-con kicks in under their seats.

So far we haven't heard any complaints from Latin American, Asian or African nations about the Qatar climate. Only certain Europeans.

Why shouldn't we adapt as do those teams from the tropics when they come to an often less-than-balmy Europe when a World Cup summer can wet, wild and windy?

My question is, if we can play sport at 40 degrees below, as in the Winter Olympics (eg Lake Placid 1980), why not 40 above?

At the moment sport's ruling bodies seem to be blowing hot and cold over whether nations which have extreme heat should be excluded from staging significant major events.

FIFA and Sepp Blatter may believe they have taken the heat out of the situation by delaying any decision on any seasonal switch for the 2022 World Cup until next year but the controversy over hotspots like Qatar extends beyond football.

The country's capital, Doha, is mounting a strong bid to stage the Olympic Games two years later and their right to do so is firmly backed by London 2012 chief Sebastian Coe.

"We can't sit any longer saying that countries prepared to invest in sport, both spiritually and in terms of infrastructure, are in some way banned or we make it impossible for them to deliver high quality sporting events," he said. "We should be encouraging it."

Former London 2012 chairman Sebastian Coe is among those who back Qatar's sporting ambitionsFormer London 2012 chairman Sebastian Coe is among those who back Qatar's sporting ambitions

The British Olympic Association chairman, speaking on a recent visit to Doha, added: "If you are going to build a global capacity in sport you are going to confront challenges. Some will be climatic, political or social. The great thing about sport is that it always manages to bridgehead change.

"My view is that we'll probably need to have a global conversion at some stage, across sport, about the calendar and the ability of some countries to stage sports events when it is climatically beneficial for the competitors. That's one of the challenges of building a global capacity for sport.

"If we said 20 years ago that Rio would host the Olympics or South Africa the World Cup, few would have believed it.

"But that's how the world works."

Doha has already bid unsuccessfully for both the 2016 and 2020 Olympics and Qatar's Olympic Committee has said they will " keep on bidding until we win".

Traditionally the Olympics, like the World Cup, take place in summer months but can be more flexible. Tokyo 1964 and Mexico City 1968 were both held in October because of the climate; similarly Sydney 2000 and Seoul 1988 started in mid-September.

Yet the hottest Games of the dozen I have attended was in a sweltering Moscow in July 1980, when temperatures soared into high nineties - and one Sebastian Coe won the first of his 1500 metres gold medals. Obviously some like it hot.

Temperatures reached over a 100 degrees when Muhammad Ali fought Joe Frazier in the "Thrilla in Manila" in the Phillipines Temperatures reached over a 100 degrees when Muhammad Ali fought Joe Frazier in "The Thrilla in Manila" in the Phillipines

That was certainly so in the Philippines in September 1975 when Muhammad Ali and Joe Frazier fought with such unremitting ferocity in "The Thrilla in Manila" - the greatest fight I have ever seen - when the ring temperature hit 110 degrees!

As it happens Qatar is not the only nation due to host a major international sports event sweating over the weather.

While the controversy surrounding the the 2022 football World Cup, approaches boiling point there is now growing concern over the climate for next February's Winter Olympics in Russia's Black Sea resort of Sochi.

Ironically, it may not be cold enough.

Forget any prospect of a bitter Russian winter sending a chill through competitors; apparently the long range forecast predicts it will be well above freezing point at what is not a natural winter resort.

Indeed Sochi, which has a sub-tropical climate for most of the year - it reminded me of Cannes with caviar when I was there a couple of years ago - seemed an eccentric choice by an International Olympic Committee swayed by the persuasive presence of President Putin when the vote was taken in Guatemala.

The average February temperature of Sochi is usually 10 degrees above freezing. Last February it was 18.5 (66 Fahrenheit) and several test events were cancelled. The current forecast suggests it may be even higher, with the possibility of heavy rain a huge threat to the skiing and and sledding events.

After similar conditions hampered the last Winter Olympics in Vancouver the IOC have been well aware of the potential weather risks to Sochi - which seem far greater to a successful Games than security, overspending or protests against Russia's rigid anti-gay laws.

Huge piles of last year's snow have been stockpiled under insulated covers in what is the world's biggest snowstoring operation.

Additionally snow cannons will be on standby in the nearby Caucasus Mountains which form a scenic backdrop to the resort but experts acknowledge it will be difficult to produce sufficient artificial snow at that temperature when it is also raining.

Not-so-cold comfort for Putin's grandiose Games plan.

The fear for the 2014 Winter Olympics and Paralympics in Sochi is not that it will be too cold, but that it will be hot, leading organisers to come up with innovative ways to ensure that there will be enough snowThe fear for the 2014 Winter Olympics and Paralympics in Sochi is not that it will be too cold, but that it will be hot, leading organisers to come up with innovative ways to ensure that there will be enough snow

Meantime, as Lord Coe says, the landscape for bids and delivery of sport around the world has changed.

"And that's a good thing. It gives more young people who haven't been touched by the magic of big sporting events a chance to experience and take up sport."

Indeed. Athletes and administrators must learn to cope with sport's own climate change, adapting to prevailing conditions wherever it may be, whether Sochi or Sudan, Qatar or Quebec.

Because, we witnessed in Mexico City, bullets are far more lethal than snow or sunstroke.

Alan Hubbard is a sports columnist for The Independent on Sunday, and a former sports editor of The Observer. He has covered a total of 16 Summer and Winter Games, 10 Commonwealth Games, several football World Cups and world title fights from Atlanta to Zaire.

Mike Rowbottom: On why Muhammad Ali never said "I am probably the Greatest"

Mike Rowbottom
Mike RowbottomMo Farah's comments this week have all but ruined two nice and simple media lines.

Firstly, Britain's world and Olympic 5000 and 10,000 metres champion has refrained from committing himself to running in next year's Commonwealth Games in Glasgow, saying it would be "a bonus" if he did it but adding "it is not on my list." Any headlines along the lines of "Glasgow a goer for Mo" will have to wait.

No decision will be taken on involvement at Glasgow 2014, Farah maintains, until he has concluded his main business of the year, namely running his first full marathon in the Virgin London event on April 13. But the multiple gold medallist has gone and spoiled everything by insisting that he will not expect to break the two-hours barrier on his debut over 26.2 miles. What a spoilsport!

Mo Farah has contradicted what he claims are 'crazy' suggestions about him running a sub-two hour marathon on his debutMo Farah has contradicted what he claims are 'crazy' suggestions about him running a sub-two hour marathon on his debut

As Farah explained, the suggestion that he was targeting such an extraordinary landmark - just a month after Kenya's Wilson Kipsang took 19 seconds off the world record in reducing it to 2 hours 03min 23sec at the Berlin Marathon – was "ridiculous", adding: "It's pretty crazy to say that in my first ever marathon I'm going to shave three minutes off.

"If you look at the world record it's slowly been broken before, from 2:04, 2:03. To say I'm going to shave that off is completely crazy.

"I don't think [two hours] is going to be broken in the next 10 years or even beyond that, maybe even 100 years, because if you think about it, it's really difficult."

A totally sensible statement. Farah has every reason to be confident given his achievements in the past couple of years, but he has never been a sportsman given to making dramatic statements of intent. Before setting a startling European 1500m record of 3min 28.81sec in Monaco earlier this year, the man now training in Oregon under the eye of former world marathon record holder Alberto Salazar hazarded only the following:

"I'm really looking forward to it. I have some happy memories of this track so if I can get near 3.33 or under it will be great. But the 1500 is a very different race from the 10k so I will just be hoping to stay in with the guys and see what I can do."

Such was the strength of the story that Farah wanted to produce the 26.2miles equivalent of the Four Minute Mile that Sebastian Coe, and even the man who broke the Four Minute Mile, Sir Roger Bannister, were drawn in to provide comment on it. Coe, with characteristic adroitness, responded that it was "very ambitious", which could have been taken as a measure of polite disbelief. Lord Coe's comments were supplemented by sage words from Sir Roger, who commented: "I don't think Mo will be ready to do it next year but it is of course possible."

ir Roger Bannister, pictured with a picture of his Four Minute mile achievement in 1954, sagely downplayed the suggestion that Mo Farah was on the brink of another athletics landmark in his first marathonSir Roger Bannister, pictured with a picture of his Four Minute mile achievement in 1954, sagely downplayed the suggestion that Mo Farah was on the brink of another athletics landmark in his first marathon

Farah has now said that the idea that he had it in mind to produce claimed that the theory was coined by his sponsors Nike, who used the term "Sub Two-Hour" for a television show they are making.

Farah, however, has now clarified the genesis of this "highly ambitious" target of his. "The rumours actually started because my sponsors, Nike, are working on a show called 'Sub Two-Hour'," he has said. "They keep working on that, and that's how the rumours started. I never actually said it."

Steve Backley, the former British javelin thrower who won Olympic and world silver as well as European and Commonwealth titles, is one of the most thoughtful characters you will ever find on the subject of sporting ambition and achievement.

Steve Backley, that most thoughtful of sportsmen, believes that many competitors have fallen under the weight of their own predictionsSteve Backley, that most thoughtful of sportsmen, believes that many competitors have fallen under the weight of their own predictions

"You do see athletes who talk themselves out of success," he once told me. "They end up putting too much pressure on themselves with predictions, and then find they can't live up to it."

Making a cautious estimation and then surpassing it is surely the course of action for any sportsman or woman. Isn't it? Well, thinking back, I suppose there have been odd examples when the bold approach has paid off. Two words exemplify it supremely: Muhammad Ali.

"I am the greatest. I said that even before I knew I was." Here is the quintessential quote from the all-time heavyweight boxing genius. But there are others which rival it in their glorious rashness – or rash gloriousness:

"If you even dream of beating me you'd better wake up and apologise."

"There's not a man alive who can whup me. I'm too fast. I'm too smart. I'm too pretty. I should be a postage stamp. That's the only way I'll ever get licked."

Muhammad Ali makes one of his predictions in 1963 - Henry Cooper will fall in round fiveMuhammad Ali makes one of his predictions in 1963 - Henry Cooper will fall in round five

Perhaps Ali's take on golf stands as his boldest of statements: "I'm the best. I just haven't played yet."

In a more serious vein, Ali attempted to explain the philosophy of his approach: "It's a repetition of affirmations that leads to belief. And once that belief becomes deep conviction, things begin to happen. "

In more recent times, predictions of success from Usain Bolt have matched those of Ali in their airy certainty, if not their colourful garb. Here is another protagonist from the School of Bold Predictions.

But for every sporting figure who lives up to his or her own hype, there is another who falls under it. I will never forget, for instance, Dave Bedford's invitation to the Great British Public before the 1972 Munich Olympics - issued exclusively in The Sun - to "stand by your beds and watch me win a gold medal for Britain" presaged a sadly predictable turn of events as he finished sixth in the 10,000m final.

A bitterly disappointing turn of events - and one which, I am ashamed to say, provoked me to land a blow on my younger brother after he made what I deemed to be a dismissive comment after we had both watched the race on TV. Verily, the bold sporting prediction is a double-edged sword. And Mo does well to avoid it.

Mike Rowbottom, one of Britain's most talented sportswriters, covered the London 2012 Olympics and Paralympics as chief feature writer for insidethegames, having covered the previous five summer Games, and four winter Games, for The Independent. He has worked for the Daily Mail, The Times, The Observer, The Sunday Correspondent and The Guardian. His latest book Foul Play – the Dark Arts of Cheating in Sport (Bloomsbury £12.99) is available at the insidethegames.biz shop. To follow him on Twitter click here.

Zara Dampney: Using the "Greatest Show on Earth" to inspire at grassroots

Emily Goddard
zara dampneyThere is a reason that the Olympic Games is often described as the "Greatest Show on Earth" and I think that anyone who saw London 2012 last year knows exactly why that is.

I was one of the lucky ones who actually got to compete at the Olympics.

Less than a month before the London 2012 Olympic Opening Ceremony, it was announced that Shauna Mullin and I would represent Team GB in the sport of beach volleyball.

It was a huge honour for us because it marked the first time ever that a British pair have featured in an Olympic beach volleyball tournament since the event made its debut at the 1996 Games in Atlanta.

The London 2012 beach volleyball setting at the iconic Horse Guards Parade was absolutely stunning and after thinking about the Olympic Games for so long, it was unbelievable to step out onto the sand in front of our home fans.

Being part of the London 2012 Olympic Games was a reward in itselfBeing part of the London 2012 Olympic Games was a reward in itself


We simply couldn't believe the support from the crowds and competing there was truly a moment I will remember for the rest of my life.

Unfortunately, we missed out on a medal but the whole experience of being part of the Olympic Games was a reward in itself for years of dedication, hard work and training.

Having been part of an Olympic Games that promised to "Inspire a Generation", I am now looking to do exactly that in my role as one of Sport England's Sporting Champions.

One of my key roles as a Sporting Champion involves supporting Sportivate projects across the country.

Sportivate is the £56 million ($85 million/€65 million) National Lottery funded Olympic and Paralympic legacy initiative run by Sport England that gives 11 to 25 year olds who aren't particularly sporty six to eight weeks' free coaching in a new sport and then helps them find low cost ways to continue to play.

Next up for me later this month is a return to a great Sportivate volleyball project at Richard Huish College in the county of Somerset.

I hope to use the magic of London 2012 to inspire young people to make sport a big part of their lifeI hope to use the magic of London 2012 to inspire young people to make sport a
big part of their life


The project is looking to get young people into the sport of volleyball and more importantly, keep them there once they are hooked.

As a Sporting Champion, I hope to use the magic of London 2012 to inspire all the young people in attendance to make sport a big part of their life.

My goal has always been to compete at the Olympics and I am now training hard with Lucy Boulton, also a Sporting Champion, to make it to the next Games in Rio in 2016. But for many children out there, the goal is simply to take part and have fun. That's the brilliant thing about sport - it can be played and enjoyed by all different people at all different levels from the elite right down to the grassroots.

And if athletes like me who competed at the "Greatest Show on Earth" can inspire young people to keep going out there to have fun and stay healthy and active, then that is yet another fantastic legacy from London 2012.

Zara Dampney is a beach volleyball player who represented Team GB at the London 2012 Olympic Games. She is now aiming to compete at her second Olympic Games at Rio 2016. Zara is also one of Sport England's Sporting Champions, which you can find out more about here.

Nick Butler: New deal for GB Canoeing illustrates professional revolution sport has enjoyed

Nick Butler
Nick Butler Olympic Stadium 2 July 24 2013 1My sporting memory is so short that names as recent as Chris Boardman and Linford Christie had hung up their spikes long before my time.

It is long enough however to appreciate the revolution undergone over the last two decades as any lingering vestiges of amateurism have been ruthlessly swept aside.

This was a thought which struck me when attending the unveiling of GB Canoeing's new kit deal with sportswear manufacturers Crewroom, which reinforced these vast changes in technology, attitude and attention to detail.

The new kit aims to make "the stars of the sport look cutting-edge but also add an advantage in competition." It is based around improving performance in training and in races, but is also about the image or, in the words of Crewroom founder Kate Giles - for want of a better term no doubt - the "sexing-up" of the sport.

Although some of the more technical details passed me by, "racing cuffs coated with grip silicone", "seamless shorts to rule out rubbing and abrasion", and a "super-fly gillet taking advantage of a water-resistant and breathable fabric" were three of the more outlandish elements.

A "carnival" theme also seeks to maximise marketing potential both on and off the water with Rio 2016 in mind.

A member of the British canoe squad gets measured up for his new kit at CrewroomA member of the GB Canoeing team are measured up for their new kit in Crewroom's part office part workshop in Putney






You do not have to look far in the world of sport to find other examples of this professionalism.

In the last week, for example, we have learned about the techniques used by tennis star Raphael Nadal to enable his recovery from a career threatening injury to win the US Open last month. In addition to the customary rehabilitation, this included the use of "bloodspinning" where blood is removed from the body, spun in a centrifuge, and then re-injected around the affected area - in Nadal's case his knee tendons.

We have also learnt more about the use of "altitude" chambers by British athletes before the London Olympics last year where they slept in tanks with artificially reduced oxygen levels and therefore forced the body to produce more red blood cells.

This is not to mention the gruelling training and recovery regimes, the precision of pre-competition preparation and the state-of-the-art kit provided by companies like Crewroom, as well as the means taken to maximise commercial worth.

This world is very different from that of the 1990s when Kate Giles was a member of the Great Britain rowing team. "I was on minimal funding so it was very different to today," she told insidethegames. "You cannot have a job now as well for example. I enjoyed combining working with training because I always liked the balance but things move on."

Giles also explained the changes in kit since she first founded Crewroom in 2001. "At first everyone wanted cotton and we had to eventually explain that it had become more technical than that. They would say 'this cotton dries out really quickly' and we'd have to say that was because it's not actually cotton!" Innocent days indeed...

Crewroom founder Kate Giles poses with the British canoe and Para canoe squads on the rainy banks of the ThamesCrewroom founder Kate Giles poses with the British canoe and Para canoe squads on the rainy banks of the Thames




In this late 1990s era lays my foremost memories of sport. It was indeed a transition time - in the first years of lottery funding after the British catastrophe that was the 1996 Atlanta Olympics, and in the immediate aftermath of the amateur to professional transition in sports such as rugby union.

My first sporting heroes were the pioneers of this new age and their professionalism was often mocked rather than applauded. The absurdity of Paula Radcliffe running 150 miles per week and rugby player Jonny Wilkinson spending hours on his own taking shots at goal and then doing it all again because he missed one kick, for example.

However, in 2003 Radcliffe's still unbroken marathon world record and Wilkinson's last minute drop goal to win England the World Cup changed this perception. These standards were gradually becoming the norm rather than the exception.

The likes of those future knights in cyclist Chris Hoy and sailor Ben Ainslie were further pioneers.

Since he agonisingly missed gold as a teenager in Atlanta, Ainslie in particular defines every element of a modern winner. He used the most ruthless of tactics to triumph against the odds at Sydney in 2000, and then overcame adversity to do so again at Athens 2004, Beijing 2008 and London 2012 where his "they did not want to make me angry speech" and subsequent domination was arguably the greatest moment of the Games. This is not even to mention his part in perhaps the greatest comeback in sporting history to win the America's Cup with Team Oracle last month...

I have had the fortune to glimpse two of these four stars in my short time with insidethegames. Casually having my lunch at the London 2012 Olympic Stadium in the press room at the Anniversary Games in July I was astonished to see Radcliffe plonk herself down on the same table and was embarrassingly too star struck to pluck up conversation.

Fast forward several months and when the chance arose to speak to Sir Chris at the Queen's Baton Relay in London I was not going to miss out.

"Sir Chris, a quick word" I said with all the confidence of a seasoned hack as I thrust my recording device in front of him and walked alongside him down the street - struggling desperately to keep pace with surely the most powerful legs in sport. The fact that I had forgotten to turn my recorder on, and thus had nothing to show for this endeavour, unfortunately shattered this confident facade...

Sir Chris Hoy clad in his kilt at the Queens Baton Relay is one of the pioneers of British sporting successSir Chris Hoy clad in his kilt (his marriage one apparently) at the Queen's Baton Relay is one of the pioneers of British sporting success


Another great pioneer was a kayaker in the recently retired Dr Tim Brabants, one of the last great champions to combine a career with his sporting success - although it is worth noting that this was an "either or", rather than a "both-at-the-same-time", kind of arrangement.

For the generation which came after these figures this professionalism has become second nature, and youngsters coming through now do not know anything else.

When having lunch - chicken and vast quantities of potatoes for the record - with members of the GB para-canoe team at the kit unveiling, I casually - and ignorantly - asked as to how the athletes surrounding me had done at the recent World Championships. "I won silver, he won gold, she won bronze and she won silver. Oh, and she behind you won three gold medals," was the reply.

Yet the refreshing thing which I noticed with GB Canoeing was how much they obviously enjoyed this lifestyle. As they measured up for their new kit, they laughed and joked and willed one of their number to fall in into the Thames as he precariously balanced his boat to satisfy one of a photographer's more ambitious whims.

However at the same time the squad had already completed one grueling training session and had another to come. They were also, unlike the journalists present, completely unbothered by the rain which unsurprisingly accompanies most of their training sessions on these shores.

This regime was described by the London 2012 gold medalist Ed McKeever who, huddled away from the limelight in jeans and his new tracksuit, emphasised both dedication and unassuming modesty.

When asked if it was hard to return to training post London, McKeever admitted that "it might have been tough at first" but seemingly without really meaning it before he described his training regime (three sessions a day) and his plans to win again in Rio.

He was similarly modest when talking about his profile post London. "I wouldn't say my profile has changed significantly - it's quite a minority sport and the successes I've had have not made too much of a difference," he admitted to insidethegames. 

"Obviously it would be nice if there was more interest and it would push up the numbers in canoeing a little bit but its just one of those things which will hopefully pick up in the future."

London 2012 Olympic champion Ed McKeever was the epitome of modesty as he described his training regime and post-kayaking career plansLondon 2012 Olympic champion Ed McKeever was the epitome of modesty as he described his training regime and post-kayaking career plans


Like his predecessor Dr Tim, McKeever also has a career and is qualifying as a chartered accountant, but he was keen to point out that this is very much for his post-canoeing future rather than the present.

It is virtually impossible to balance training to win the Olympics with working in the modern world.

The great thing now and most of all in British sport is that success is very much on a conveyer belt. Just as Brabants was followed by McKeever as the king of the Great Britain team, among the many young athletes huddled in the Crewroom workshop another star will surely be unveiled at Rio 2016 or beyond.

The Crewroom partnership, with all of its professional ethos of the modern day, will only aid this process.

Even if we may miss the halcyon days of amateurism nothing beats the success of the revolution inspired by Ainslie and Wilkinson, Brabants, Radcliffe and Hoy and the foundations that have been laid for today.

Nick Butler is a reporter for insidethegames

Alan Hubbard: Sport is in Helen Grant's DNA

Emily Goddard
Alan HubbardAny of the more macho elements in sport who think the new British Minister for Sport and Tourism is a soft touch because she is a woman are in for a shock.

Helen Grant is more than capable of fighting her corner, as she demonstrated during her upbringing as the only black kid on a council estate in Carlisle by taking up judo to help defend herself against racist abuse.

"It was in the sixties," she recalls. "For a while I was the only person there with a darker skin. There was prejudice, and bullying. But I dealt with it.

"I went into judo to defend myself thinking, 'well, if they see I'm good at it they won't pick a fight with this one'."

The message was duly absorbed and she did become good enough to be an under-16 champion for the north of England and southern Scotland. At school, she was captain of the school tennis and hockey teams, and represented Cumbria in hockey, tennis, athletics, and cross-country.

After studying law at the University of Hull, she went on to become a solicitor, an MP and now, at 52, a surprise appointment as Sports Minster following Hugh Robertson's elevation to the Foreign Ministry.

Helen Grant took up judo as a child to help defend herself against racist abuseHelen Grant took up judo as a child to help defend herself against racial abuse



"A dream come true," is how she describes the summons to 10 Downing Street to insidethegames.

So why did the Prime Minister give her then job?

"You'll probably have to ask him but I know he was aware of my passion for sport because we have discussed it many times," Grant said. "And he obviously thought I would be a good advocate for it.

"My aspiration was always to be an Olympic judo champion but in the end I became a lawyer and got into politics. However, sport has never left me. It is very much in my DNA.

"It gave me time to think and insulated myself from the idiots I had to deal with when I was growing up at school. It was the thing that gave me self-confidence and self-esteem."

And this slim and vivacious married mother of two strapping sons - Ben, a Royal Marine commando and rugby-playing Joel, about to go to university - clearly has that in abundance.

Born in London to an English mother and Nigerian father, when her parents separated she grew up in a single-parent family as the only black resident on Carlisle's Raffles estate for much of that troubled early childhood where sport, she says, made her a winner.

Now she must win over sport itself. "Already I can see there is lots to do in sustaining the legacy of 2012 both for sport and the economy."

Helen Grant says it was sport that made her a winnerHelen Grant says it was sport that made her a winner




Naturally, the continuing advancement of women's sport is high on her agenda. "There's lots more to do. We need to shape sport to make it attractive to women, particularly young women."

She wants to see more women on governing bodies and in administrative positions, "though things do seem to be progressing there", she says.

"I still think there are chauvinistic attitudes, not just in football but a number of areas. We want people to compete fairly, to strive for equality. Sexism has got to be dealt with."

While she still plays tennis with husband Simon, swimming is not listed among her many athletic accomplishments. But she was thrown in at the deep end with footballer Jack Wilshire's "England for the English" controversy. It is one in which she declines to be immediately immersed, pointing out that she has barely got her feet under the Ministerial table in here airy office on the fourth floor of the Treasury building in Westminster, where the Department for Culture, Media and Sport now lodges.

"I'm not going to wade into that," Grant explains. "It's seems a matter for the FA and the England manager and I have yet to meet the governing bodies to discuss it. But what I will say is that I have a zero tolerance attitude towards any form of discrimination - racism, sexism, homophobia, xenophobia - whatever. Also all unsportsmanlike behaviour, like spitting, gouging, abuse of referees. Absolutely zero tolerance."

Unlike Robertson, who was a Minister of State, Grant will be a junior Minister, sharing her sports role with that of her existing equalities and portfolio, and tourism.

But she strongly refutes the suggestion that sport has been demoted. "What nonsense," she scoffs. "Sport is now more important than ever. It is critical to the welfare of this country. I believe he [David Cameron] has appointed me because he feels I'll be an advocate for it as a force for good."

Alan Hubbard is a sports columnist for The Independent on Sunday, and a former sports editor of The Observer. He has covered a total of 16 Summer and Winter Games, 10 Commonwealth Games, several football World Cups and world title fights from Atlanta to Zaire.

Mike Rowbottom: Jack Wilshere's common cause with George Orwell - the quest for what it means to be English...

Mike Rowbottom
Mike RowbottomThis week's comment by Arsenal and England footballer Jack Wilshere that "the only people who should play for England are English people" has provoked a widespread reaction throughout a number of sports.

England cricket's naturalised South African batsman Kevin Pietersen was among many to have responded to the suggestion, asking the talented midfielder on Twitter: "Interested to know how you define foreigner? Would that include me. [Andrew] Strauss, [Matt] Prior, Justin Rose, [Chris] Froome, Mo Farah? Same difference..It's about representing your country! IN ANY SPORT!"

Wilshere's comments came in the wake of a discussion over the future international status of Manchester United's 18-year-old Adnan Januzaj, who is eligible for selection by Belgium, Serbia, Albania and Turkey, but will, under FIFA rules, be eligible to play for England if he remains in this country for five years.

ack Wilshere's comment this week that only English people should play for the England team has raised a familiar and inconclusive debateJack Wilshere's comment this week that only English people should play for the England team has raised a familiar and inconclusive debate

Before we go any further, just to make it clear that this is not an article about Jack Wilshere, it should be pointed out that his comment has been 100 per cent backed by former England captain Alan Shearer, who told BBC Sport: "I am of the opinion that to be English you should be born in England... Januzaj looks a fantastic young talent. But just because you've lived in England for five years that doesn't mean you can play for the national team."

South Africa's cricket captain Graeme Smith would presumably agree with Shearer's take on this issue, as he has has clearly never forgiven his former teammate Pietersen - who was born and raised in South Africa but has an English mother - for electing to play for his adopted country of England. "I'm patriotic about my country. And that's why I don't like Kevin Pietersen," Smith has gone on record as saying.

All this latest hoo-hah has taken place on the very day when the Queen launched the Baton Relay for the 2014 Commonwealth Games in Glasgow, an event which will, once again, focus minds on what it means to be English, or Scottish, or Welsh, or Northern Irish, as opposed to being British.

Mo Farah, multiple Olympic and world champion for Britain, was born in Somalia. So does that make him not British?Mo Farah, multiple Olympic and world champion for Britain, was born in Somalia. So does that make him not British?

Wilshere's comments, at one level, are perfect sense. Of course only English people should represent England. But how do we define English people? Ay, there's the rub, as a very English playwright once put it...

Shearer's yardstick of representing the country in which you were born has an elemental appeal.

But let's think for a moment of one of the lasting images of English football: Terry Butcher, captain and central defender, leaving the pitch after helping England earn the goalless draw against Sweden in Stockholm that ensured qualification for the 1990 World Cup, his face, shirt, shorts and socks all showing evidence of blood that has poured from a bandaged head wound. Having had stitches inserted, Butcher had returned to the fray and made a conspicuous number of defensive headers.

In times of despair - and there have been a few - England supporters have loved to recall this iconic devotion to the cause of the Three Lions. But Butcher was not born in England. He was born in Singapore. So by Shearer's criterion, he should never have been on that pitch in Stockholm.

Terry Butcher gave blood for England to help them qualify for the 1990 World Cup finals. But this Three Lions icon was not born in EnglandTerry Butcher gave blood for England to help them qualify for the 1990 World Cup finals. But this Three Lions icon was not born in England

In 2011, UK Athletics introduced some competitors to its team who had lately competed for other nations - a circumstance which earned them criticism from some quarters of the media for being 'plastic Brits'.

The man responsible for this turn of events was Charles van Commenee, the Dutchman appointed as head coach of UK Athletics in 2008. His position was the same one espoused this week by the former Football Association chairman David Bernstein, who has said England must "play within the rules and get the best team we can".

One of the newcomers, high hurdler Tiffany Porter - born and raised in the United States, but entitled to a British passport through having an British mother - found herself at the centre of feverish debate when, at a press conference ahead of the 2012 World Indoor Championships, she was challenged to sing the National Anthem by a reporter.

Many newspaper columns were subsequently written on the question of whether Britain should expect its sporting performers to know the words and tune of "God Save the Queen". And if Porter had, would that have proved she was British?

There is an uncertain swirl of response to these circumstances within Britain - it is similar to the kind of debate which took place when Swede Sven Goran Eriksson became the first foreigner to take charge of the England football team. Eriksson's foreignness faded almost into the background when England enjoyed a superlative 5–1 win over their ancient rivals, Germany;
but as the Eriksson momentum failed, usually around the quarter-final stage of any tournament worth winning, he became a foreigner once again.

In rugby, as in football and athletics, there have been periodic outbursts of complaint over players switching to play for different national teams. Shortly before taking England on their ultimately ill-fated journey to the 2011 World Cup in New Zealand as manager, Martin Johnson, who had captained England to World Cup victory eight years earlier, spoke in liberal tones about the whole issue with the sport.

Acknowledging the criticisms that had been raised over England squad members such as Manu Tuilagi and Thomas Waldrom, whom some saw as operating under a flag of convenience, Johnson recalled his own time as a young player spent in New Zealand, whose under-21 side he played for.

Martin Johnson, who led England to the 2003 Rugby World Cup and subsequently managed the England team, commented: "It's what you do and who you are...not particularly where you are born."Martin Johnson, who led England to the 2003 Rugby World Cup and subsequently managed the England team, commented: "It's what you do and who you are...not particularly where you are born."

He told the Independent: "People don't understand, talking about our guys born abroad. They've got to come in and prove themselves like anyone else. If we think they're the right people and the right characters then they can play... It's what you do and who you are, not particularly where you are born."

But then if you waive birthplace as a means of determining nationality, surely you need to retain a blood link? Of course, it's all relative, ultimately, as we reflect on the nomadic history of humankind over time. But the logical end point of Johnson's argument seems to be that you can play for England if you have what the US astronaut programme used to call the "right stuff"
about you - that is, if you have the right kind of "English" stuff .

So we return to the question. What is "English stuff"?

Wilshere had a bash at defining this. "We have to remember what we are. We are English. We tackle hard, are tough on the pitch and are hard to beat. We have great characters. You think of Spain and you think technical but you think of England and you think they are brave and they tackle hard. We have to remember that. "

But then Wilshere was once described by his manager at Arsenal, Arsene Wenger, as having "Spanish technique, but an English heart."

And we return to the question. What is an "English heart"?

George Orwell listed a liking for a "nice cup of tea" as among the quintessential national characteristics in his essay "England Your England"George Orwell listed a liking for a "nice cup of tea" as among the quintessential national characteristics in his essay "England Your England"

At the end of his 1941 essay entitled "England Your England", George Orwell concludes that, though the Stock Exchange may be pulled down, and the horse plough may give way to the tractor, and the country houses may be turned into children's holiday camps, and the Eton and Harrow match forgotten, "England will still be England, an everlasting animal stretching into the future and the past, and like all living things, having the power to change out of recognition, and yet remain the same."

In his casting around for essentially English characteristics, Orwell came up with two straight away. They were, firstly, a tendency towards "'privateness", as evidenced by a predilection for hobbies and pastimes such as stamp collecting and comforting things like the fireside and the "nice cup of tea".

And secondly, a love of flowers.

Is this helping?

Personally, I feel most closely identified with that old red cross on white when I eat toast and marmalade. Maybe that's something to do with my grandpa. He was very English.

I feel English too when I indicate to a fellow customer that they are due to be served before me.

Or when I watch England's football team fail to win the World Cup. Or the European Championship.

The further abroad I go, the more likely I am to take with me a book written by a quintessentially English writer, such as Kingsley Amis, Philip Larkin or Evelyn Waugh.

So I think, putting this all together, the answer to the Wilshere question is plain enough. Then again, what do I know? I was born in Edinburgh.

Mike Rowbottom, one of Britain's most talented sportswriters, covered the London 2012 Olympics and Paralympics as chief feature writer for insidethegames, having covered the previous five summer Games, and four winter Games, for The Independent. He has worked for the Daily Mail, The Times, The Observer, The Sunday Correspondent and The Guardian. His latest book Foul Play – the Dark Arts of Cheating in Sport (Bloomsbury £12.99) is available at the insidethegames.biz shop. To follow him on Twitter click here.

Philip Barker: From long jump pit raker to first Queen's Baton Relay runner, Allan Wells has come a long way

Duncan Mackay
Philip BarkerAllan Wells has become the first runner to receive the Glasgow 2014 Baton from The Queen and believes it will have an even greater impact in Scotland than the arrival of the Olympic Flame in 2012.

"The reaction to the Torch Relay in Scotland was phenomenal " said Wells, a bearer in Selkirk in June last year. "I got a call from Seb Coe afterwards and told him how well it had been received.

"I do feel that we might even be able to give more to the Baton Relay. We have that opportunity with a home Games that are actually in Scotland."

Wells, the 1980 Olympic 100 metres champion, was spearking after a ceremony at Buckingham Palace that was dignified colourful and very Scottish. There was even a violinist to bring back memories of Sir Yehudi Menuhin's tour de force at the 1986 Opening Ceremony of the Commonwealth Games in Edinburgh

Wells' own association with the Commonwealth Games goes back over 40 years. He was a volunteer steward in Edinburgh's Meadowbank Stadium in 1970, the first time the Games were held in his home country.

"My job was to rake the long jump pit," he recalled. "In fact most of the time I was watching. Lynn Davies. He was a hero of mine I also kept an eye on the reactions of the runners in the 100 metres. The atmosphere was so tense. It was something that really inspired me. "

By the time the Commonwealth Games returned to Edinburgh in 1986, he had made such an impact on them that he was chosen to present the Baton to Prince Philip, then President of the Commonwealth Games Federation. It proved the only time Wells would wear the blue Scottish vest that summer. He was controversially left out of their team for the Games.

"I'd done the qualifying times, I even had the suitcase with all the kit, but they wanted me to prove my fitness," said Wells. "I did everything they asked me to but didn't get picked"

In 1986, Wells had been escorted into the Meadowbank Stadium by athletes Ian Stewart, Lachie Stewart, Rosemary Payne, Rosemary Stirling, boxer Tom Imrie and fencer Sandy Leckie, all gold medallists from 1970.

"When I ran in, I could hear people shouting look he's fit, he is running," said Wells. "They couldn't understand why I wasn't in the team "

Wells had won four Commonwealth gold medals over the two preceding Games and believes, to this day, that he would have enjoyed success in front of his home crowd. To prove the point he won against his main rivals in a meeting shortly afterwards. He believes that a medal in Commonwealth Games athletics remains one of the hardest to win, particularly in his own events where most expect Usain Bolt to take centre stage next year.

"It 's no garden party," said Wells. "The focus is every bit as great as at the Olympics."

Allan Wells described receiving the Baton from the Queen at Buckingham Palace as "up there with winning a gold medal"Allan Wells described receiving the Baton from the Queen at Buckingham Palace as "up there with winning a gold medal"

Now almost 28 years on, Wells finds himself at the heart of the latest Commonwealth Games to be held in Scotland.

"I was probably the proudest Scot on the podium today," he said after receiving the Baton containing the Queen's Address dressed in a kilt of Ramsay tartan from his mother's side of the family. "This was up there with winning a gold medal.

"The Baton is unique, completely different to the Olympic Torch Relay. There is only one Baton. My fingerprints will be on the Baton until the end and it will be the same for everyone else."

Commonwealth Games Federation President Prince Imran Tunku called it "the world's most engaging relay ". At 288 days this time it is longer than any journey of the Olympic Flame.

The ceremony will have brought back memories for Prince Philip. He was,characteristically, fascinated by the intricacies of the new baton, so very different from the silver gilt model he had set in motion for the first such relay to Cardiff. In 1958.

Although there had been international sections before 1998, it was the journey to Kuala Lumpur which first made the handover of the Baton a spectacle in its own right. Traditional Malaysian dancers and drummers beating Kompang drums gave colour to a bright spring morning, which also happened to be Commonwealth Day and set a precedent for a cultural display at Buckingham Palace.

So too did the large escort for badminton star Punch Gunalan. In earlier years there had been a maximum of two. In 2002 for Manchester there were fireworks from the top of the Palace and for Melbourne, in 2006, even a supermodel.

Australian supermodel Elle McPherson jokes with Prince Philiip at the start of the Queen's Baton Relay for Melbourne 2006Australian supermodel Elle McPherson jokes with Prince Philiip at the start of the Queen's Baton Relay for Melbourne 2006

Elle Macpherson was chosen to receive the Baton as a representative of Australia before it began its journey to Melbourne. That was a decision which would not have passed muster with Federation officials in earlier years. They insisted the "first runner should be a medallist of the preceding Games."

In recent years too, the Queen has placed herself sealed the message inside the Baton in full view of the crowd. The 2014 baton is illuminated to show the message but not the text.

The Pipes and Drums of the Scots guards and band of the 1st Battalion of the Royal Regiment of Scotland provided the music. To the strains of "A Scottish Soldier" and "Hielan Laddie", a kilt wearing Sir Chris Hoy, had brought the baton to Buckingham Palace. This had pleasant echoes of 1982 when Decima Norman, a great Australian champion from Sydney 1938, had flown from Brisbane as custodian of their baton. Then, already aged 72, she was not asked to carry it along the Mall.

The first international stopping point of the 2014 journey will be in India to acknowledge the most recent hosts. It will also recall the two most recent relays. The Baton visited the Taj Mahal in both 2006 and 2010.

Born in Hackney, a stone's throw from the 2012 Olympic Stadium, Philip Barker has worked as a television journalist for 25 years. He began his career with Trans World Sport, then as a reporter for Sky Sports News and the ITV breakfast programme. A regular Olympic pundit on BBC Radio, Sky News and TalkSPORT, he is associate editor of the Journal of Olympic History, has lectured at the National Olympic Academy and contributed extensively to Team GB publications.

Alan Hubbard: So, farewell Hugh Robertson, welcome Helen Grant as Britain's new Sports Minister

Duncan Mackay
Alan HubbardSo Britain has a new Sports Minister. Helen Grant's background suggests she is very much the sporty type, but the question does she know anything about it? Or more pertinently, about overseeing it?

While hers seems a predictably politically correct appointment - only the second female and first black custodian of the games we play - it is also a potentially exciting one. If she proves up to the job.

The shock appointment of the 52-year-old solicitor following Hugh Robertson's elevation to the Foreign Ministry means that with the Culture Secretary Maria Miller - with whom she already works as Equalities Minister - as her boss at Department of Culture, Media and Sport ,the governance of sport here is now very much a women's world.

Women are now filling more key posts in sport than ever, and that's a good thing, though there are some dinosaurs, notably in football, who will disagree. Get real, chaps. The glass ceiling is splintering and about time too.

Presumably Robertson knows her well as she represents a neighbouring constituency in Kent. So did he recommend her for the job?

Helen Grant leaves Number 10 Downing Street after being told by Prime Minister David Cameron that she will be replacing Hugh Robertson as Britain's Sports MinisterHelen Grant leaves Number 10 Downing Street after being told by Prime Minister David Cameron that she will be replacing Hugh Robertson as Britain's Sports Minister

Someone must have because as far as sport is concerned she is unknown. But not for long, for hers is a formidable pedigree.

A former judo champion and the Conservative Party's first black female MP, she has replaced Robertson in a reshuffle which promotes the dapper former Army officer to work as adjutant to William Hague as a Minister of State.

Grant's subsequent appointment comes from left field. Literally, actually, as she was once a member of the Labour Party but switched to the Tories in 2006, saying:"It was almost looking in the biscuit barrel, not liking the look of the biscuits, and slamming the lid shut."

She was later parachuted into Ann Widdecombe's safe seat in Maidstone ahead of the 2010 General Election. Last year she was made Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Justice, Women and Equality.

Born in London to an English mother and Nigerian father, when her parents separated she grew up in a single-parent family as the only black resident on the Raffles council estate in Carlisle for much of her early childhood, where she admitted to suffering racist abuse.

At school she was captain of the school tennis and hockey teams, and represented Cumbria in hockey, tennis, athletics and cross-country. She was also an under-16 judo champion for the North of England and Southern Scotland.

After studying law at the University of Hull, she went on to become a solicitor. She is married with two sons, one of whom is serving in the Royal Marines.

Grant's personal website still lists tennis among her hobbies, as well as attending sporting events - and she immediately used her Twitter account to highlight England's crucial World Cup qualifier against Montenegro on Friday. "I cannot wait to get started and certainly am hoping for a great result for #England against Montenegro on Friday!" she posted.

As yet we don't know which team she supports - if any. But she will have to get the political kit on soon if she is to pick up where Robertson left off in knocking heads together at the Football Association and Premier League.

But it is the fulfilment of London 2012 legacy that must remain paramount in her in-basket, together with the continued provision of adequate funding at elite and grassroots level via the Exchequer, UK Sport and Sport England.

Schools sport is also a high priority following the restoration of £150 million ($240 million/€179 million) of Government funding and we look forward to her showing the Education Secretary Michael Gove a touch of the harai-goshi should he try to renege on any Government pledges in this area

No doubt Robertson will be passing on some sage advice too. In my view, he has been outstanding in a long line of Sports Ministers, certainly in his three year tenure the best the Tories have ever sent into bat in their cricket team of incumbents. He has always played the bowling as straight as the answers he always gave the media.

Hugh Robertson has been among Britain's best ever Sports Ministers - but will not be missed by officials at the Football Association, who he has consistently criticisedHugh Robertson has been among Britain's best ever Sports Ministers - but will not be missed by officials at the Football Association, who he has consistently criticised

Sport will miss him, all except those running English football who will be glad to see the back of him - because he has always been on theirs, labelling the football authorities as the worst-run of any in sport.

Sepp Blatter and his FIFA cronies who have been equally intransigent over the pressure he has applied for reform at the highest level will also clap their hands at his departure.

Robertson, 50, had turned down previous offers of a more senior role in Government and in his six years as Shadow Minister but this seems to be one he couldn't refuse in terms of career advancement.

It is rare for a Sports Minister to go onwards and upwards to higher office, apart from into the House of Lords (though Colin Moynihan did become Energy Minister). For most it has been a bit of a dead end job.

Now London 2012 is out of the way, has Britain's Prime Minister David Cameron decided to downgrade the importance of sport?Now London 2012 is out of the way, has Britain's Prime Minister David Cameron decided to downgrade the importance of sport?

Now the worrying concern is that, in promoting Robertson, David Cameron appears to have demoted sport.

Grant will be a junior Minister, unlike Robertson, sharing her Under-Secretary's sports role with that of the equalities portfolio.

Does this indicate that with the Olympics done and dusted Cameron no longer sees sport as having the political and social clout of the past three years? Let's hope not.

Grant picks up the baton at a time when British sport is on a high. Her job will be to help it remain so, and get others playing it , as she has demonstrably done herself.

I suspect the personable ex-athlete will be a hit with sportsfolk once she settles in and should she emerge as capable-and feisty - as her only female predecessor, Kate Hoey, it will be a bonus.

But she will find sports politics as murky, devious and capricious as the real thing. Maybe more so.

I wish her well, and hope she proves as adept at throwing some weight around as she was on the judo mat.

Alan Hubbard is a sports columnist for The Independent on Sunday, and a former sports editor of The Observer. He has covered a total of 16 Summer and Winter Games, 10 Commonwealth Games, several football World Cups and world title fights from Atlanta to Zaire.

Marc Naimark: The Gay Games' mission is to promote equality in and through sport

Duncan Mackay
Marc Naimark I write to you from Cleveland, Ohio, which, with Akron, will host the 2014 Gay Games next August. I'm a member of the Board of the Federation of Gay Games (FGG), here with 20 other Board members and more than 50 delegates from our member organisations, for our Annual General Assembly.

The first half of our meeting will be devoted to the choice of the host for the 2018 Gay Games, which will be the tenth edition of the world's largest sport and culture festival open to all, with no requirements other than being age 18 and over and paying the registration fee.

The final decision is due to be announced tomorrow.

Joining us will be the delegations from Limerick, London, and Paris, the three cities shortlisted as finalist by our Assembly last June. The delegations will include Olympic fencing medalist Laura Flessel and French Minister for Sport Valerie Fourneyron. The presence of such high profile personalities is a sign of the perception of the impact hosting the Gay Games can have for a city.

French Sports Minister Valérie Fourneyron and fencer Laura Flessel, who carried her country's flag at the Opening Ceremony of London 2012, will be part of the Paris delegation bidding for the 2018 Gay GamesFrench Sports Minister Valérie Fourneyron and fencer Laura Flessel, who carried her country's flag at the Opening Ceremony of London 2012, will be part of the Paris delegation bidding for the 2018 Gay Games

Financial impact, of course. Hosting over 10,000 athletes and artists and tens of thousands more friends, family, and fans brings in significant revenues for a host city. Unlike the Olympics and other mega-events, the Gay Games doesn't require infrastructure investments, and the tourists who attend do not displace normal visitors.

Beyond finance, there is a political impact. The Gay Games are not about rewarding good LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender)-friendly countries and punishing bad LGBT-phobic countries.

Of course the FGG is not going to ask participants to travel to a place that is unsafe. But part of our mission is to promote positive change in the cities and regions to which we bring the Games, a goal exemplified by our host for 2014 in Northeast Ohio, where among the many changes taking place are LGBT sensitivity training sessions for the police and diversity training for regional providers of goods and services for the Games.

There's a moral impact as well. The mission of the Gay Games is to promote equality in and through sport. In our site selection process for 2018, we have for the first time explicitly requested that bidders discuss their vision for human rights, including the fundamental impact of the Games itself.

The Federation of Gay Games is a volunteer organisation run on a shoe-string budget. Our host committees have paid staff and a budget that at several million dollars remains a tiny fraction of those of Olympic hosts. When we do have a bit of money, our reflex is to spend it on scholarships to support participants from developing countries.

Akron and Cleveland will host the 2014 Gay GamesAkron and Cleveland will host the 2014 Gay Games

For many of us, the choice of a host of the Gay Games is the most important task of the FGG.

To make this decision, we require hosts to produce a thorough bid book covering a range of issues including venues, finance, marketing, conference plans, etc. We created an online form so that anyone in the world could ask bidders for explanations and further details on their plans, and published those questions and the answers from bidders on our website.

For the first time we invited all qualified persons from around the world to apply for the position of site inspector, chose three, and sent them to spend four days in each of the three finalist cities. From these visits a 100-page report was prepared, reviewed by bidders, and sent to voters.

And now here in Cleveland, we'll spend three days on site selection, including committee reports, site inspection presentations, and the highlight of the event, the oral presentations before we make our final choice. 

Marc Naimark is vice-president for external affairs for the Federation of Gay Games, the governing body for the world's largest sporting event open to all, and a member of the Pride House International coalition of LGBT sport and human-rights organisations. Gay Games 9 is due to take place in August 2014 in Cleveland.


Nick Butler: Tradition, inclusivity and power of Flame emphasised once again as Sochi 2014 takes up the Torch

Nick Butler
Nick Butler Olympic Stadium 2 July 24 2013 1Wandering around the track before the Sochi 2014 Olympic Handover Ceremony - chuntering incoherently to myself no doubt about my inability to navigate the Greek metro - I experienced a rare moment of lucidity.

Last week at the Flame Lighting Ceremony I stood on the Olympian hillside at the home of the Ancient Olympic Games. Now this week I am at the home of the Modern ones - on the very Panathenaic Stadium track where Spyridon Louis won the first Olympic marathon 117 years ago.

Such is this life of privilege on Torch Relay patrol.

Far greater than its ability to satisfy ceremony attending journalists however, is the Relay's ability to provide memories and opportunities for all people from all backgrounds and from all countries.

The Relay, and in particular the two Ceremonies so far, have done this in such a traditional and almost effortless way.

While the Flame Lighting Ceremony at least had the difficulty of a long drive to Ancient Olympia the Handover Ceremony - metro incompetence aside - had not even that handicap.

Greek figure skating champion Panagiotis Markouizos lights the cauldron during the Sochi 2014 Olympic Torch Handover CeremonyGreek figure skating champion Panagiotis Markouizos lights the cauldron during the Sochi 2014 Olympic Torch Handover Ceremony

As a mixture of Olympic enthusiasts, locals, and curious tourists took their seats, there was no mad rush, no ticket touts on the gate and no intricate seating system.

The long, stone corridor which wound its way to the press room was anything but modern until you would suddenly pop out in the relatively hi-tech media room in an image that reminded me of  the James Bond film The Spy who Loved Me.

Out of the most historical of settings - the Pyramids of Egypt I believe - Bond stumbles upon the most state-of-the-art of hidden rooms containing an alliance of British and Soviet secret service. Modern features hidden away in an ancient setting in the same way.

Back in Greece and two hours later the same corridor had transformed into a bustling hub of back stage preparation as the stadium gradually adopted an atmosphere blending that of a village fete with an international sporting event.

The James Bond imagery however remained. The difference was that instead of an Anglo-Soviet partnership in a Cold War era conflict, it was a Greco-Russian alliance combating the Olympic themes of peace and friendship.

Like last week there was no commercialism, needless advertising and tacky memorabilia on show. Perish the thought, there was also no "kiss-cam" or "bongo-cam" as the grotesque Americanisms which are ruining British sport stayed blissfully absent.

In fact, except for the much cooler weather and the substitution of International Olympic Committee President Thomas Bach for the President of the Hellenic Republic, Karolas Papoulias, all of the Ancient Olympic hillside charm remained unblemished in Athens.

This undiminished charm of entertainment in its most pure and traditional form is the message that shines through about the Greek Torch Relay as a whole. Children, athletes and everyone in between has joined together to celebrate both the past and the present.

Not even a political context which, with the clampdown against Golden Dawn politicians, has arguably deteriorated even more in the last week could dampen the spirits. Nor could the torrential rain: which may have flooded the streets but not the ambitions of the participants.

One of these was Greco-American Matthew Hotos - nominated for his work for a charity targeting breast cancer – who was carrying an Olympic Torch for the third time after  doing so previously before Athens 2004 and London 2012.

Torchbearer Matthew Hotos carried the Flame on Tuesday midway through its six day journey around GreeceTorchbearer Matthew Hotos lights the Flame on Tuesday midway through its six day journey around Greece


"Even though the host country is different every time, there is no bigger honour and mystic then carrying the torch in Greece," he said. "You feel a connection with the Ancient Games and feel that you are continuing the passing of the flame through the ages as the next generation ahead of you will do - a tradition that will continue on and on.

"I always get nervous before my run.I have that butterfly feeling in my stomach because you know that for 300 meters all eyes are on you - it is such an overwhelming honour and privilege that you are in awe of what is happening. You hear the cheers and congratulations and for a minute you become the local celebrity."

It is this ability to make the ordinary seem extraordinary, and the normal person the celebrity, that is this great charm of the Relay.

Unlike Hotos and colleagues at insidethegames, the closest I got to the London 2012 Relay was a rainy weekend in Durham. Spending hours huddled shivering under an umbrella - or not in my case - in summer temperatures which can only be found in the North East of England waiting to see gymnast turned television personality Matt Baker troupe in Torch in hand.

Despite almost catching pneumonia by the time of his delayed arrival I was soon setting my alarm for the following morning to see the Torch leave the city in the hand of another sporting star, cricketer Paul Collingwood, with my mood of excitement for the pending Games suitably enhanced.

In the case of Britain it is easy to forget it was the Torch Relay which destroyed the ambivalence surrounding the Games. Before the Relay: headlines surrounded cost, security threats and predictions of failure. After it the mood of what the Mayor of London Boris Johnson memorably described as the "Geiger counter of Olympomania" had been set in motion never to be extinguished.

By all accounts the success in Greece, despite the political woe and suspiciously "Durham-like" weather, the Torch has done the same thing and lifted the spirits of the country.

With the handover to Sochi 2014 now complete we can expect more of the same in the weeks and months ahead on Russia soil. A four month route encompassing 83 regions, journeying by reindeer, sledge and hot air balloon and travelling to the North Pole and Outer Space, it is fair to see that the focus is on scale rather than subtlety. With a country the size of Russia there appears little choice.

Russian Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Kozak holds aloft the Olympic Torch after it has been passed to Sochi 2014Russian Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Kozak holds aloft the Olympic Torch after it has been passed to Sochi 2014

Yet the key point is that like in Britain and Greece, and Canada and China beforehand each host country adds its own charm and characteristics to a Torch Relay which is defined by its ability to adapt to all terrains. Beginning in Moscow with a visit to the Red Square the Russian leg will provide excitement at every turn.

However, like in James Bond's The Spy who Loved Me there will also be the chance for Russia to work together with others so as to best display the Olympic themes.

After the success of today's Handover in another mystifying yet satisfying ceremony, there is every hope that this is what will occur over the coming months before the Opening Ceremony on February 7.

With all the great history that Russia, like Greece, has to offer, there will also be every chance for more moments of lucidity for those mindful of the history of this great event along the way.

Nick Butler is a reporter for insidethegames

Philip Barker: A brief history of the Queen's Baton Relay, whose modest roots have grown into a worldwide event

Duncan Mackay
Philip BarkerThe London 2012 Torch Relay ignited Olympic fever in the United Kingdom and for the first time the flame visited Scotland. Now an even longer relay, lasting 288 days, will next Wednesday (October 9) bring a greeting from the Queen from Buckingham Palace to Glasgow, host city for the 2014 Commonwealth Games via 71 countries across the world.

When the first "British Empire Games" were held in the Canadian city of Hamilton in 1930, Canadian Prime Minister Richard Bennett read words of King George V to the crowd. Ever since, the Royal message has been a part of the Opening Ceremony.

The first Games of the Queen's reign were held in Vancouver in 1954. She was represented by Prince Philip on that occasion, but the Queen intended to be there in person for the 1958 Games in Cardiff.

The Welsh were determined to put on a show. In 1956, they had celebrated the centenary of the composition of their national anthem "Land of My Fathers". Welsh Athletics official and schoolteacher Bernard Baldwin organised a ten mile "Lawr y Cwm" (Mountain to Valley) race. One runner, 1948 Olympic marathon silver medallist Tom Richards, carried a Baton containing a goodwill message from the people of Mountain Ash to Pontypridd.

Sam Ferris, another British Olympic marathon medallist was there to greet the runners in Pontypridd.

"I believe it is Baldwin's ambition to persuade Cardiff Corporation to further the cause of road running by organising another Lawr y Cwm as a finale to the 1958 British Empire and Commonwealth Games," he said.

That didn't happen but Baldwin's efforts may well have been part of the inspiration for the first Queen's Message Relay in 1958. It was a very modest affair by modern standards, all completed in less than a week.

The Baton was designed by soldier turned Cardiff jeweller Colonel Roy Crouch and featured the Welsh dragon in bold relief, the daffodil and leek. Silversmiths Messrs Turner and Simpson of Birmingham manufactured the batons.

The man put in charge of the logistics of the event was Commander Bill Collins, a retired Royal Navy officer, who had also organised the London 1948 Olympic Torch relay.

Sir Roger Bannister is flanked by Chris Chataway and Peter Driver at the start of the Queen's Baton Relay for the 1958 Commonwealth Games in CardiffSir Roger Bannister is flanked by Chris Chataway and Peter Driver at the start of the Queen's Baton Relay for the 1958 Commonwealth Games in Cardiff

Prince Philip met the first three runners at Buckingham Palace. The first bearer was Dr Roger Bannister, the first sub-four minute mile runner in history winner of the "Miracle Mile " at the 1954 Games in Vancouver. Two other champions from those Games, Chris Chataway, winner of the three miles in Vancouver, and Peter Driver, the six miles champion, provided an escort.

In the courtyard, an equerry handed the Baton to Collins before the trio departed through the Palace Gates.

Sir Roger ran to Kensington Gardens. Canadian High Commissioner George Drew and Welsh Minister Henry Brooke were waiting to greet him. The two men represented the host nations of the immediate past and present Games.

Athletic clubs and schools were asked to provide runners. Seniors ran for two miles and juniors half that distance, accompanied at all times by the support vehicle, a Rolls Royce.

The Relay headed to North Wales and crossed the border at Chirk shortly after dawn. Rowing was part of the Games programme in 1958 and held in North Wales. Competitors at Lake Padarn took a break from training to watch the Baton pass. Twins Irfon and Elfyn Roberts, pupils at Caernarvon Grammar School and 14-year-old schoolboy David Pell from Friars School in Bangor were among the youngest of the 664 runners.

Runners from the Mountain Rescue service helped carry the Baton at Llanberis.

Over the next three days it headed South and along the coast to Cardiff. The message was then switched to a special Ceremonial Baton and carried into Cardiff Arms Park by Welsh sprinter and Rugby Union international Ken Jones.The Queen's words spoke of "welcome proof of the increasing value which is being placed today of physical strength and skill as an essential factor in the development of the whole man.I hope that many lasting friendships will grow.

Welsh sprinter Ken Jones hands the Queen's Baton to Prince Philip at the Opening Ceremony of Cardiff 1958Welsh sprinter Ken Jones hands the Queen's Baton to Prince Philip at the Opening Ceremony of Cardiff 1958

The message signed off: "I am greatly looking forward with being with you at the end of next week."

In fact, the Queen was too unwell to attend the Closing Ceremony so a recorded message relayed by loudspeaker announced Charles would become Prince of Wales.

By the time Charles was invested in 1969, the Queen had still not attended a Commonwealth Games, but the following year they were to be held in Scotland for the first time. Edinburgh was host city and Royal College of art student Hector Miller designed a Baton which featured the Games symbol and the city coat of arms.

For the first and only time, the Baton began its journey outside the UK. The Queen was visiting Canada. She handed over her message at Petitot Park at Yellowknife in the North-Western Territories.

"What message could the Queen have in mind that requires such a circuitous route for its conveyance? " asked Auberon Waugh in The Times."One cannot help feeling that it had better be something pretty meaty to justify the effort."

Commander Collins, in Canada to supervise the handover, fired off a rebuke. "Those who give their services in Canada and Scotland in organising this small traditional contribution to the Games are only too glad to do something for others in the world of sport without thought of reward for themselves," he wrote. "The young people of Scotland who will be carrying the message feel it an honour to do so."

First Nation ethnic groups, including those from Inuvik took part in the Handover Ceremony. Abby Hoffman, Canada's 1966 gold medallist over 880 yards, received the Baton from the Queen. It was flown to Scotland where 21-year-old John Ferguson of Ayr Seaforth Harriers was the first of 1,000 runners on Scottish soil. "Thus many distant places from Edinburgh would feel they were playing some part in Scotland's Games," said organisers.

When it passed through Glasgow it fell to teenager Doreen Arthur to present the baton at Glasgow City Chambers.

Finally it arrived in Edinburgh and it was fitting that this long distance journey should be completed by a marathon runner, 1966 gold medallist Jim Alder who handed the Baton to Prince Philip to read the message. The Queen arrived later in the week to close the Games.

The Queen took part in the Closing Ceremony at Edinburgh in 1970, the first occasion that Scotland hosted the Commonwealth GamesThe Queen took part in the Closing Ceremony at Edinburgh in 1970, the first occasion that Scotland hosted the Commonwealth Games

In 1986 the Games returned to Edinburgh. The Relay began at Buckingham Palace. The Baton designed by Edinburgh jeweller Michael Laing, was handed to Steve Cram accompanied by champion hurdlers, Australia's Debbie Flintoff and England's David Hemery.

The Baton travelled through England, Wales, the Channel Islands and the Isle of Man before reaching Coldstream, where Alder, the final runner in 1970, now carried it across the border. It was transported across Scotland by runners and cyclists and arrived in Edinburgh for the Opening Ceremony. In contrast to 1970, organisers chose a sprinter this time. Allan Wells ran in, escorted by six gold medallists from the 1970 Games.

Many countries boycotted in 1986 over Britain's stance on sporting contact with South Africa, so the Queen's words, read by the Duke of Edinburgh seem particularly poignant. "The Games have a well deserved reputation for their friendliness and good sportsmanship," he told the crowd at Meadowbank Stadium.

The Queen will open Glasgow 2014. When this happens, her speech is officially styled an "address" not a "message". The first time she opened the Games was at Edmonton in 1978. Kenyan runner Ben Jipcho received a baton made from a Narwhal tusk by Inuit artist Nick Sikkuark outside Buckingham Palace. It was flown to Canada where surviving medallists from 1930 offered a welcome in Hamilton Ontario.

It visited all the Provinces before Diane Jones-Konihowski, soon to win pentathlon gold, handed it back to the Queen. "In recent years, as your President, Prince Philip has performed the Opening Ceremony and read my message," she told the assembled crowd. "Today the roles are reversed and for the first time I am able to give you my message in person."

The Queen also opened the 1994 Games in Victoria, British Columbia. It was carried on traditional first nation canoes before 1994 Olympic biathlon champion Myriam Bedard entered the Centennial Stadium on dry-land skis in an unusual finale.

Unlike the Olympic Flame, there is no danger of the baton "going out", but in 1974 it did go missing from an office before the Relay to Christchurch New Zealand had even begun. It was found just in time.

Organisers of the 1990 Games in Auckland were inventive. The Baton was divided and visited New Zealand's North and South Islands. In 1998, after a symbolic journey to all the continents, It arrived in Kuala Lumpur,and the final journey to the Stadium began by elephant .

Seb Coe was the first runner to have his pulse rate tracked by the 2002 baton which passed through more Commonwealth countries than ever before. Crowds swarmed to Manchester to see football stars past and present from City and United take part, including brothers Phil and Gary Neville. Sister Tracey was part of England's netball team.

David Beckham hands the Queen's Baton to six-year-old Kirsty Howard at the Opening Ceremony of the 2002 Commonwealth Games in ManchesterDavid Beckham hands the Queen's Baton to six-year-old Kirsty Howard at the Opening Ceremony of the 2002 Commonwealth Games in Manchester

The most spectacular moment came when acrobat Lindsey Butcher descended into the City of Manchester Stadium by balloon baton in hand. The Queen, celebrating her own Golden Jubilee, then greeted David Beckham and six-year-old Kirsty Howard who presented the "address".

Even Her Majesty described the 2006 baton as "Hi Tech". Her Melbourne address visited all 71 Commonwealth nations and beamed back sound and pictures throughout .For the Queen it was "a symbol of the unity and diversity of our commonwealth of nations".

Four years ago, a London taxi ride gave the Baton an unusual start on its 340 day journey to Delhi. It visited the source of the Nile and was even the star attraction at a wedding in St Vincent. The Baton changed colour to reflect the flag of each nation it visited.

Now a journey of 190,000 kilometres to Celtic Park in Glasgow lies ahead of the 2014 Baton, the design inspired by Charles Rennie Mackintosh. The contents are illuminated although the actual words of the Queen's address cannot be seen.

Born in Hackney, a stone's throw from the 2012 Olympic Stadium, Philip Barker has worked as a television journalist for 25 years. He began his career with Trans World Sport, then as a reporter for Sky Sports News and the ITV breakfast programme. A regular Olympic pundit on BBC Radio, Sky News and TalkSPORT, he is associate editor of the Journal of Olympic History, has lectured at the National Olympic Academy and contributed extensively to Team GB publications.